Difference between revisions of "Talk:Twin Hydradrive Knight"
(→Wording) |
m (→Wording) |
||
Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
This card and "[[Tesseract Hydradrive Monarch]]" (and any other monsters with the same effect) currently have their effect-negating effect worded as "''Negate the effects of monsters with the same Attribute(s) as this card while your opponent controls them.''" I don't think this is the best wording (per translation), as it implies (or could at least be interpreted as) two things I believe to be incorrect: (1) It negates the effects of any such monsters, not just those on the field; and (2) It negates your monsters effects, not just those of your opponent, and would negate the effect itself provided your opponent has a monster sharing an Attribute. More accurately, I think it should be "''Negate the effects of monsters your opponent controls with the same Attribute(s) as this card.''" Thoughts? Thanks. - [[User:Bhigpx|Proxygen]] ([[User talk:Bhigpx|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Bhigpx|contribs]]) 20:48, 27 February 2019 (UTC) | This card and "[[Tesseract Hydradrive Monarch]]" (and any other monsters with the same effect) currently have their effect-negating effect worded as "''Negate the effects of monsters with the same Attribute(s) as this card while your opponent controls them.''" I don't think this is the best wording (per translation), as it implies (or could at least be interpreted as) two things I believe to be incorrect: (1) It negates the effects of any such monsters, not just those on the field; and (2) It negates your monsters effects, not just those of your opponent, and would negate the effect itself provided your opponent has a monster sharing an Attribute. More accurately, I think it should be "''Negate the effects of monsters your opponent controls with the same Attribute(s) as this card.''" Thoughts? Thanks. - [[User:Bhigpx|Proxygen]] ([[User talk:Bhigpx|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Bhigpx|contribs]]) 20:48, 27 February 2019 (UTC) | ||
− | : The text seems fine to me. "While your opponent | + | : The text seems fine to me. "While your opponent controls them" means that they have to be on the opponent's field; otherwise, they're not negated. [[User:MadRest|MadRest]] ([[User talk:MadRest|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/MadRest|contribs]]) 02:04, 2 March 2019 (UTC) |
Latest revision as of 02:04, 2 March 2019
This is the talk page for discussing the page, Twin Hydradrive Knight. | |
---|---|
|
Please try to
|
Wording[edit]
This card and "Tesseract Hydradrive Monarch" (and any other monsters with the same effect) currently have their effect-negating effect worded as "Negate the effects of monsters with the same Attribute(s) as this card while your opponent controls them." I don't think this is the best wording (per translation), as it implies (or could at least be interpreted as) two things I believe to be incorrect: (1) It negates the effects of any such monsters, not just those on the field; and (2) It negates your monsters effects, not just those of your opponent, and would negate the effect itself provided your opponent has a monster sharing an Attribute. More accurately, I think it should be "Negate the effects of monsters your opponent controls with the same Attribute(s) as this card." Thoughts? Thanks. - Proxygen (talk • contribs) 20:48, 27 February 2019 (UTC)