Forum talk:WDC Week 1

From Yugipedia

Jump to: navigation, search

Judging Criteria[edit]

Judges, the criteria is below.

Relativity: (Out of 5 points): This justifies how much the deck is related to the topic and how the entrant approached it. If it was creative and showed the intention of creating a new way, the entrant receives full points.

Efficiency: (Out of 10 points): This justifies how the deck achieves a flow of fast and powerful. If the entrant used ways to maximize efficiency, he or she receives full points.

Playability: (Out of 5 points): This justifies how much the deck is playable - how it is seen through others' eyes. For example, if this deck was given to a very random player, could they grasp the concept and use it to its full potential? If the entrant used ways to maximize playability, he or she receives full points.

Overall Power: (Out of 5 points): This justifies how the deck performs against decks circulating in the TCG. If it shows much potential and what judges judge to be powerful, then the entrant receives full points.

Scoring Area[edit]

Judges please place your scores below.

Invasion! - Gemini69:
- R - 4 (An Alien deck, but it also takes advantage of them being Reptiles)
- E - 8 (Plenty of ways to distribute A counters and use them)
- P - 4 (Most people would know how to use this deck, though the first few turns might be kinda rough)
- O - 4 (Can hold its own against most decks)
  - Total: 20/25

Mars Attacks! - Rein Weiss Ritter
- R - 4 (Alien deck, but also uses stall cards)
- E - 9 (Good use of stall cards)
- P - 5 (I think most people could use this deck)
- O - 4 points (Would do pretty well, though it may need more S/T removal)
  - Total: 22/25

ET Attack - Teba64
- R - 3 (It's an Alien deck, but not much is new)
- E - 9 (Definitely takes advantage of A counters and their distribution)
- P - 4 (Can be used by most players, though some more than others)
- O - 5 points (Definitely has potential)
  - Total: 21/25

Cosmic Plague - Baccus78
- R - 5 (A hybrid Alien/DARK deck, that's new)
- E - 9 (Very good at crippling opponent's monsters)
- P - 4 (Most players could duel with this deck)
- O - 5 (Would do well against most decks)
  - Total: 23/25

Aliens: Requiem - Darkdust Dragon
- R - 5 (Very good use of non-Alien cards)
- E - 9 (Good Graveyard manipulation)
- P - 4 (most could use it, might take some getting used to, since it is rather different from the usual Alien decks)
- O - 4 (a very good deck)
  - Total: 22/25

Theres no fancy alien name here - Agent Error
- R - 4 (Weakens enemies and forces them to attack, nice)
- E - 9 (Takes advantage of Alien effects and supports them)
- P - 4 (Quite playable)
- O - 4 (Overall, a pretty good deck)
  - Total: 21/25

Reptile Take-Over - Romanovajax
- R - 3 (Venom monsters have their own deck type)
- E - 7 (Needs a few more "staple" cards like Monster Reborn, Heavy Storm)
- P - 4 (playable, but the Vennominon might throw people off)
- O - 3 (could be better; wouldn't do quite as well against current decks)
  - Total: 17/25

- Bluedog187 17:58, 9 August 2008 (UTC)

Invasion! - Gemini69
- R - 3 (normal alien build; one copy of Evil Dragon backfired on creativity)
- E - 7 (limited spell and trap efficiency)
- P - 4 (nicely playable)
- O - 3 (alien decks are judged down for overall due to its weakness versus the meta)
  - Total: 17/25

Mars Attacks! - Rein Weiss Ritter
- R - 3 (normal alien build)
- E - 8 (well-rounded spell and trap lineup)
- P - 4 (nicely playable)
- O - 3 (same as above O rating)
  - Total: 18/25

ET Attack - Teba64
- R - 3 (normal alien build; was not surprised at one copy of D.D. Warrior Lady)
- E - 8 (versatile spell and trap lineup)
- P - 4 (nicely playable)
- O - 3 (same as above O rating)
  - Total: 18/25

Cosmic Plague - Baccus78
- R - 4 (good use in infusing Dark aspects)
- E - 8 (fine spell and trap lineup, but could find replacements; example: Shrink over Riryoku)
- P - 4 (nicely playable)
- O - 3 (same as above O rating)
  - Total: 19/25

Aliens: Requiem - Darkdust Dragon
- R - 4 (well-rounded but not totally original)
- E - 7 (after all the previous decks, your spell-trap lineup was almost identical and boring)
- P - 4 (nicely playable)
- O - 3 (same as above O rating)
  - Total: 18/25

No-Fancy - Agent Error
- R - 4 (well-done in creating a reinforcing attack manipulation)
- E - 7 (mortified at the lack of Monster Reborn and Premature Burial, but nevertheless well done in attack manipulation)
- P - 4 (nicely playable)
- O - 4 (although in small quantities, this deck will prove itself to some measure - thank you for negation)
  - Total: 19/25

Reptile Takeover - Romanovajax
- R - 2 (poorly constructed with Venom monsters)
- E - 6 (weak spell and trap lineup; mortified at the loss of certain cards)
- P - 3 (incongruent gameplay)
- O - 3 (incongruent gameplay)
  - Total: 14/21

Chris427 06:23, 9 August 2008 (UTC)

Invasion! - Gemini69
- R - 3 (Basic alien build not much new)
- E - 7 (Good use of Counters,but could use more good control cards like Mass Hypnosis
- P - 4 (Very playable)
- O - 3 (it could hold alright)
  - Total: 17/25

Mars Attacks! - Rein Weiss Ritter
- R - 4 (Good build, nothing new)
- E - 8 (very good use of counters and monster protection)
- P - 5 (Very easy to play with and uses commonly found cards such as Swords of Revealing Light)
- O - 4 (It would do pretty well)
  - Total: 21/25

ET Attack - Teba64
- R - 3 (It's a good alien deck but all the same)
- E - 8 (Good use of counters and control)
- P - 4 (Nicely playable)
- O - 4 (Pretty good)
  - Total: 19/25

Cosmic Plague - Baccus78
- R - 4 (very different and good)
- E - 8 (Hurts your opponent bad, but Eradicator Epidemic Virus does not have enough targets)
- P - 4 (good)
- O - 4 (Very good)
  - Total: 20/25

Aliens: Requiem - Darkdust Dragon
- R - 3 (Nice approach to the aliens but nothing new)
- E - 7 (Spell and Trap cards could be better Again more Mass Hypnosis!
- P - 4 (very playable)
- O - 3 (Good but could be better)
  - Total: 17/25

No-Fancy - Agent Error
- R - 4 (Good aliens and the Burden of the Mighty is a nice touch)
- E - 8 (Good Dark Bribe is very nice but weres Monster Reborn and Premature Burial)
- P - 5 (very easy to play with)
- O - 4 (Pretty good I'd say negation is good)
  - Total: 21/25

Reptile Take-Over by Romanovajax
- R - 3 (sorry venom does not work here)
- E - 6 (The same as the other decks but no Monster Reborn, or Premature Burial)
- P - 4 (Easy but venom messes it up)
- O - 3 (pretty weak sorry)
  - Total: 16/25

Dragon of chaos 19:05, 9 August 2008 (UTC)

Retrieved from "https://yugipedia.com/index.php?title=Forum_talk:WDC_Week_1&oldid=724600"