Talk:Elemental Hero Deck

The "recommended cards" list here is terrible. Hero Kid is bad, Avian is bad, Burstinatrix is bad, Bubbleman is bad, Clayman is bad without Giant Rat, Necroshade is bad, Bladedge is bad, Ocean is bad outside of Big City, Woodsman is bad, Wroughtweiler is bad, King of the Swamp is bad, Polymerization is bad, Super Polymerization is bad, Feather Shot is bad, De-Fusion is bad, Skyscraper is bad, Bubble Blaster is bad, Bubble Shuffle is bad, Bubble Illusion is bad, Burst Return is bad, Fake Hero is bad, H-Heated Heart is bad, O-Oversoul is bad, HERO Flash is bad, Cyclone Boomerang is bad, Spark Blaster is bad, Hero Heart is bad, Fusion Gate is bad, Hero Signal is bad, Feather Wind is bad, Clay Charge is bad, Edge Hammer is bad, Kid Guard is bad, Miracle Kids is bad, Hero Spirit is bad, Change of Hero - Reflector Ray is bad, Hero Counterattack is bad, Elemental Recharge is bad, and Hero Barrier is so insultingly bad that I can only conclude that whoever made this list is some kid who watches the GX anime far too much and doesn't actually know how to play. In fact, the whole list is just a list of random E-Hero support cards. Permission to make MAJOR changes to the list?--Crab Helmet 05:37, 21 April 2008 (UTC)

• Well, apparently it never occurred to you that no card is 100% bad and that someone out there has made these cards work. Stop whining about cards you don't like. Rodtheanimegod4ever 06:20, 21 April 2008 (UTC)

• This is a list of "recommended cards". Presumably, recommended cards are cards that are worthy of being recommended. Take Hero Barrier, for example. It is exactly like Mirror Force, except undeniably worse. It is exactly like Magic Cylinder, except undeniably worse. It is exactly like Draining Shield, except undeniably worse. It is exactly like Negate Attack, except undeniably worse. It is exactly like Sakuretsu Armor, except undeniably worse. It is exactly like Dimensional Prison, except undeniably worse. It is exactly like Threatening Roar, except undeniably worse. But are Mirror Force, Magic Cylinder, Draining Shield, Negate Attack, Sakuretsu Armor, Dimensional Prison, and Threatening Roar listed here? No. However, Hero Barrier is listed here. Why? Not because of what it does. Not because it's worth using. It's listed here because it has "Elemental Hero" written in its text. That is the ONLY reason.

A list of "recommended cards" should be designed to help players decide how to build a deck. Throwing together a list of cards with "Elemental Hero" in their text doesn't help anyone. Therefore, I propose that one of these three changes be made:

1. Replace the entire list of recommended cards with {{hero}}, since the only real difference is that {{hero}} lists Mirror Gate (and since no card is 100% bad, I'm sure that someone out there has made Mirror Gate work).

2. Add Larvae Moth to the list of recommended cards. No card is 100% bad, so I'm sure that someone out there must have made it work.

3. Fix the list of recommended cards so that someone on earth might actually benefit from it.

Take your pick.--Crab Helmet 06:52, 21 April 2008 (UTC)

Duuh, I have an Elemental Hero deck that is great for duels. Actually, you just need a little customization for this deck to work, like replacing one card for another. Acsys55 07:29, 21 April 2008 (UTC)

This is Wikia, not Metagame. Information on cards that fit the E.Hero theme are exactly what should go here. If you want to list E.Hero cards that go in a "good" deck you might as well just replace the whole page with a single link to Elemental Hero Stratos. Danny Lilithborne 07:39, 21 April 2008 (UTC)