Forum:July 2014 Banlist Predictions

From Yugipedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Opening

Prio just came out today, and we have about two months before the new banlist will be released (July banlist is for the TCG and OCG). I don't really know what to think of the OCG banlist anymore...but my TCG predictions for July 13 are these:

Banned:

  • Black Luster Soldier - Envoy of the Beginning - Not very likely to happen, but it's one of two ways to kill the Primal Seed Loop (the other being put Primal Seed back to 1).
  • Blaster, Redox, Tempest, and Tidal - I have had enough of this deck. Kill it with fire. It keeps finding a way to win even if you give it the slightest inch of vitality.
  • Necroface - The semi-limit on this card was one of the stupidest moves Konami ever made. If it's not banned then back to 1 at least.
  • Red-Eyes Darkness Metal Dragon - Key card of the Hieratic OTK and allows for too many good combos in other dragon decks as well.
  • Dark Hole - The last of the power spells, while it's losing its staple status, it's still strong enough to warrant a ban.
  • Rekindling - Might as well ban it by now, Lavals can use Soul Charge instead (which I think should be hit as well).
  • Royal Tribute - With all the support Gravekeeper's had in Legacy of the Valiant last January, they don't really need this card anymore. It's a turn 1 win-button like Gateway and Offering, both of which are also banned.

Limited:

  • Bujingi Crane - Bujins have gone on for a while now with no hits, this is the most likely thing to happen to them. If they decide to keep them alive for Worlds in August, this'll likely happen the list after.
  • Dark Magician of Chaos - If Dark Hole and/or Rekindling go, this can almost certainly come back without any issues.
  • Karakuri Shoguns Burei and Bureido - Not as likely, but it's one less OTK combo the game has to deal with.
  • Mermail Abyssteus or Abyss-Sphere - Gunde was the wrong hit for the deck in April, this is what should've happened.
  • Madolche Hootcake - They won't hit Anjelly because it's new and it's not the issue with the deck. While limiting Hootcake won't stop them from searching and reusing it, banning it is probably too harsh.
  • Sinister Serpent - Not as good as it once was.
  • Thousand-Eyes Restrict - TER is no better than number 101 and he could honestly go to 3 at this point, but knowing Konami they'd test him at 1 first.
  • Dragon Ravine - If the 4 Dragon Rulers finally get banned, then this can come back to 1 to assist slower decks like Dragunities.
  • Primal Seed - Again, either this, or ban BLS.
  • Soul Charge - Fairly powerful card, but I wouldn't outright ban it just yet; unlike Reborn, you play LP to use it and you lose your battle phase that turn. I think those restrictions would balance it out at 1.
  • Artifact Sanctum - The key card to Artifact decks, but like Anjelly and Crane, they might leave them as they are until the banlist after worlds.
  • Geargiagear - Slows down Geargias.

Semi-Limited:

  • Dark Armed Dragon - Could come down to 2 like the OCG did, it's not as good as it once was and only rogue decks use it anymore.
  • Debris Dragon - Doesn't need to stay at 1 if the Rulers get banned. It could even come down to 3 like the OCG did.
  • Gladiator Beast Bestiari - Gladiator Beasts do nothing anymore.
  • Neo-Spacian Grand Mole - Not really that good anymore, it needs to attack to get its effect and no one would run it at 2 except rock stun, which is meh.
  • Allure of Darkness - If and only if Necroface gets banned.
  • Reinforcement of the Army - Warrior decks don't do that much anymore.

Unlimited:

  • Burner, Lightning, Reactan, and Stream - If the 4 daddy rulers go, these can come off the list.
  • Magician of Faith - No one runs it anymore because it sucks. To positive infinity.
  • Mermail Abyssgunde - Switch places with Teus and/or Sphere.
  • Advanced Ritual Art - Ritual decks are bad nowadays and unlimiting this won't change that.
  • Gold Sarcophagus - If the Rulers and Necroface go to 0, this can come off the list with no issues.
  • Sacred Sword of Seven Stars - Not run outside of Rulers, which need to be banned.

Whew, that's quite a long list, and while I don't think all of these will happen, worlds is gonna be a mess if the TCG and OCG don't come to an agreement soon. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 22:02, May 16, 2014 (UTC)

So it begins.
Is the Primal Seed loop actually doing things? I complained about it too but forgot to actually check if it was ....well a thing. Faggot Dragons need to die. I would say slow and Painful, but that basically sums up ......their entire history after the first hit. While they deserve it, i don't see artifacts being hit so soon. I wouldn't mind seeing Gunde staying where she is in addition to the Teus and sphere...................Basically i agree with everything but Sinister serpent, a free card is a free card to discard.DreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 22:14, May 16, 2014 (UTC)
Well, yeah the Primal Seed loop isn't that consistent, but neither were the loops or OTK's involving Morphing Jars 1 and 2, yet they got banned; I thought TCG Konami wanted to kill all loops regardless of relevance. The Rekindling limit this format was another example of such. My argument on unbanning Serpent remains the same as it always has: one, it's not really infinite discard fodder since it only returns during your standby phase and most effects that discard happen during your main phase, two, decks that could use it like Mermails or Dark Worlds have better things to pitch that get effects immediately when you pitch them, instead of during your next turn, and last but not least, a +1 like Serpent isn't really a +1 unless you can effectively take advantage of it, which most decks can't. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 23:00, May 16, 2014 (UTC)

I also think that Bujins should get hit, I mean they have Crane, Honest and now also Sinyou! I thought Blackwings were unbalanced with 3 Kalut but that takes it to a whole new level.

As much as I hate Dragon Rulers, I don't know if I want them to get banned since they can also help non-Dragon decks (i.e. Redox in X-Sabers, Blaster in Laval etc.). IMO they should just errata them, so you can no longer banish Dragons to summon them. This would make them far more balanced and make it impossible to abuse their effects, although I don't think this will happen.

Aside from your suggestions, I really want to see Judgement Dragon to get Limited. Lightsworns will get new support soon (in the TCG, in the OCG they already got it) and will make them even more broken. Hitting the Dragon, and maybe Solar Recharge at 2, will make the Deck more balanced.

--BronzeJohnson (talk • contribs) 15:36, May 23, 2014 (UTC)

New support is probably a good reason for them to not hit them.........Who the hell thought JD was a good idea, they should have put a larger cost or make it die to its own effect tooDreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 18:39, May 23, 2014 (UTC)
Going by Konami-Logic, hitting JD wouldn't make sense, but it would by a balancing standpoint: As you mentionned, a monster with high ATK and DEF values that is too easy to summon and has an amazing effect, and to top it all off it isn't even limited. And now Lightsworn get a new Bossmonster in the form of Michael.
Honestly, Konami should stop sniffing it's own farts and start to adress the numerous balancing issues in the game.
--BronzeJohnson (talk • contribs) 19:18, May 23, 2014 (UTC)
While JD could be hit, I don't think he will anytime soon. Maybe 2 at most, but 1 or 0 probably isn't going to happen. Also, hitting just Solar Recharge is big enough on it's own and seriously hurts the deck. If Recharge is hit, leave JD alone, LS isn't bad enough to warrant murdering the deck. Also, Michael isn't really a great boss (He's just good), as Life Points kinda matter if you want to run Soul Charge. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 16:37, May 25, 2014 (UTC)

Socialgames:

Banned: Daddy Rulers, Baby Rulers, Honest, Exciton Knight, BLS, Beelze

I Honestly Think Honest Should Be Banned Because He Is An Ass Saver,Also It Pisses Many Competitive People Off.

Limited:Soul Charge,Lonefire,Supervise,Monster Reborn,Stratos,JD,Heavy Storm,Wave Motion Cannon,Future Fusion,Hyperion,Odd Eyes Pendulum Dragon,Infernity Archfiend,Laval Volcano Handmaiden,Level Eater,Pot Of Avarice,Card Trooper,Chaos Sorcerer,Tour Guide,Tenki,Bear,Gorilla,

JD Is The OTK Card,Summon 1 Pop Field Then Summon 2 More From Hand,Supervise Is Like This:Tribute Lonefire Special Giga Plant,Use Eff Special Lonefire Again,Eff Lonefire,Tribute Summon Gigaplant Use 2nd Supervise,Special Lonefire Use Eff,Summon Another Gigaplant,Use Another Supervise And Use Eff To Special Lonefire And Tribute For Tytannial.Exactly 10K DMG!!!

I Honestly Hate Burn Deck.Getting Motion Banned Is Very Good Limit Card

Soul Charge Is The Comeback Of Pendulums:Use Torrential,Then Use Soul Charge,Bring Them Back. Odd Eyes Pendulum Dragon:The Searcher Of Your Trouble. Infernity Archfiend:The Card That Can Be Troubleous. The Only Quasar Way:Laval Volcano Handmaiden.

Semi-Limited:Bottomless,Macro Cosmos,Rescue Rabbit,Skill Drain,Rai-Oh,Mound Of The Bound Creator,Allure Of Darkness,Ice&Fire Hand,Reinforcement Of The Army,Malicious,Plague,Trish.


Unlimited:Formula Synchron,Dandylion,Night Assaliant,Dimensional Prison,Mirror Force.


Thank YouSocialgames (talk • contribs) 12:23, June 6, 2014 (UTC)

If you ban the Daddy Rulers, you don't need to keep the Baby Rulers banned, the Babies do absolutely nothing without the bigger Rulers. People have outlined above & below why Reborn and Heavy can't come back, Pot of Avarice shouldn't be a card, Stratos should stay banned as Dark Mist will come out later this year. Wave Cannon is too reliant on not getting destroyed. Future Fusion can't be Limited while Chaos Dragons exist as a deck. You can't limit Tenki, Bear, and Gorilla as that would kill Fire Fist as a deck, if anything, you can only justify a hit on Tenki. Of you deal with Soul Charge, Maiden isn't that bad, yes she makes Quasar, but so do Plants. Pendulum Summoning would be too new for the TCG and Odd-Eyes wouldn't be hit, I agree that the search then going to the Extra Deck isn't the fairest way thing to do, but the summoning system is too new. Don't see much of a reason to Limit Trooper, I'd honestly be okay if it went to 3, as Kuribandit is arguably a better card for milling. Archfiend isn't an issue with the deck, the stuff it searches was. The Supervise thing isn't bad, as you need to have 3 Supervise and 1 Lonefire; getting 3 exact copies of a single card is hard, even with Hidden Armory a thing. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 13:29, June 6, 2014 (UTC)

First Of All My Wish Is To Limit Stratos Because Heroes Are My Fav Archetype,Future Fusion Because I Want To Use It,Beelze Banned Because He Is Very Abusive.Ban The Baby Rulers Just To Get Rid Of The Annoying E-Drags.IK That Pendulums Wont Be Hit Because Konami Wants To Make Money Out Of Them,But Atleast Limit Odd Eyes,I Hate FFs Thats Why Limit EM ALL!!!.Trish Limited Because I Have A Wish To Use It.Thats Why Limit Lonefire Because It Makes Quasar,I Bet That Next Year,Sylvan The Meta Plant So It Should Prob Get Hit.Stratos And The Fire Fists Are Just Personal Preferences.Socialgames (talk • contribs) 12:04, June 10, 2014 (UTC)

I understand that you're list is a wish, but generally it's a good thing to base some of the choices off facts. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 13:17, June 10, 2014 (UTC)

Dark Ace SP's Thoughts

Banned

  • The Rulers

Limited

Notes:

  • I don't think Primal Seed is that bad. Mostly because it's like a five-card OTK.
  • While I used to want DMOC back, I think that he's just too powerful. Yes, there's nothing really bad that he could bring back now, but if he's around, wouldn't Konami have to nerf future cards just to keep him around? I'd rather have strong and good spells than DMOC back. While Faith is at one, the merits of using a weak Flip-Effect monster kinda balance her out. While DMOC is simple to dump into the grave with Lavalval Chain, then revive using Call of the Haunted. Plus a Dark Magician of Chaos, Call of the Haunted, and D.D.M. - Different Dimension Master deck is really viable in my opinion.
  • Necroface could go back to one. However, even at two, Gold Sarc could probably be dropped to 2-3.

Semi-Limited

  • Reinforcement of the Army - I'm mixed on this one. I feel like ROTA has been stuck here for way too long. Yes, it'll give HEROs one more search card, but the reality is that HEROs already have like 6, not counting the future E-HERO Dark Mist.
  • Dark Armed Dragon - Yeah, he could go to two. No one uses him except Chaos Dragon and some Zombie/Blackwing decks as a deck. I think Shaddolls use him too, but I'm not sure on that.
  • Mole - Yeah, he's cool, but Mole isn't really used today, maybe as a side-deck card, but even then.
  • Debris if Tempest leaves.

Unlimited

  • ARA
  • Reborn Tengu
  • Sacred Sword if Rulers leave

--Dark Ace SP (Talk) 16:52, May 26, 2014 (UTC)


Banned

  • Dragón rulers
  • Beelze
  • Cyber network coz every multi banished monster rb is banned

Límited

  • Blackwing kalut same as honest eff
  • Black sonic is a súper mirror force
  • Cyber dragón nova
  • Brain control
  • Heavy storm
  • Judgment dragón
  • Goyo guardián isnt to strong now
  • Graceful charity
  • Morphing jar
  • Monster rb
  • Many six samurái. Cyber. Fairy and other monster type are stronger now....

Semi

  • Bottomless trap hole
  • Compulsory
Scorpion2099 (talk • contribs) 17:40, May 27, 2014 (UTC)
Beelze isn't powerful enough to warrant a ban. Yes, he's a beatstick, but he's not overpowered. Number 101, Phoenix Wing Wind Blast, and a few other cards deal with him easily. Not to mention Breakthrough Skill and Fiendish Chain make him really weak. While counter arguments aren't always amazing to use, in Beelze's case, there are quite a few ways to work around him. Cyber Network isn't Return from the Different Dimension, they are very different cards. Network, if used by it's own effect, takes 3 turns to use, and the monsters you summon can't use their effects and you can't conduct your Battle Phase. If you blind MST and destroy it, it's kinda your fault.
Kault was once at 1, but Konami dropped him to 3 over a few formats because Blackwings got power-creeped. Even though BW is still a good deck, and has taken a few Top 8 spots this format, it's not a game-breaking deck, and is seen more as a rogue deck. As for Sonic, it's restricted to only BWs and even though its a superior Mirror Force, if it will be hit, it will be semi-limited, because it works exactly like Mirror Force, except with a more permanent form of removal. Also, Dimensional Prison, which only removes one monster is also Semi-Limited. You can't really Limit a restriction-laced card if it's more general cousins are both Semi-Limited. Brain Control isn't coming back because there is no restriction on what the monster can be used for, and I can make the argument that Mind Control should also be banned.
Charity is never coming back, mostly because it's cost is no longer a cost. This game has evolved to the point where monsters in the grave are very easy to bring back. With Call of the Haunted at 3 and a few other Revival cards, drawing 3 cards, then ditching two monsters for later is a very beneficial play. Not to mention that Dark World will gain their effects when used with Charity. Would you like your opponent to draw 3 cards, then get the effects of a Grapha, Dragon God of Dark World and Snow, Magician of Dark World/Broww, Huntsman of Dark World?
Monster Reborn isn't coming back, if you want revival, use Call of the Haunted, which is at 3. Morphing Jar shouldn't come back, not only is it part of the FTK with Morphing Jar 2 or itself, Creature Swap, Jackpot 7, and a bunch of cards to change battle position of an opponent's monster. Empty Jar also uses the same principle, but the Jackpot 7 deck doesn't need to deck your opponent out, it just needs to get lucky on turn number one. Not really sure BTH should go to 2, Traptrix Myrmeleo is great, no need to turn it into amazing. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 02:30, May 28, 2014 (UTC)
I mentioned earlier that counters can justify cards sometimes, it just depends on how powerful it is when it's unable to be countered, and Beelze is just a giant 3k beatstick on hos own. We're not in 2003 anymore, beatdown decks aren't tier 1. Cyber Dragons aren't that good...there's no reason to ban/limit their main cards. Brain Control, charity, Heavy Storm, Morphing Jar, and Reborn won't be coming back, neither will Goyo and JD doesn't need a hit. Compuls to 2 is possible, but Bottomless is searchable through traprix myrmeleo, it should stay at 1. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 12:36, May 28, 2014 (UTC)

My July 2014 Predictions

Banned:

Black Luster Soldier - Envoy of the Beginning: This guy has made lots of people rage quit. Basically a Chaos Sorcerer (Who is semi right now) on steroids and more.

Dark Armed Dragon: Oh hey, lemme just get a 2800 beater and destroy 3 cards you control.

Evil Swarm Exciton Knight: Generic-nonsuicidal-easytosummon-blackrose.

Limited: Bujingi Crane or Bujingi Turtle: One of these things needs to go.

Mermail Abyssphere: Because Linde.

Number 101 Silent Honor ARK: Prevents destruction and takes any special summoned monster. Ew.

Semi-Limited: Gorz the Emissary of Darkness: No one uses him. He deserves some love.

Unlimited: Thunder-King Rai-oh: Either 3 or 1. He isn't very threatening unless you special summon big monsters a lot or you are Bujins, and even then, is easy to get over.

Ray.tanner.10 (talk • contribs) 01:28, May 28, 2014 (UTC) Taco the Magic Dragon

Dark Armed Dragon is cool, but he's more likely to go down to 2 than to 0, simply due to the fact that he isn't widely used, and just isn't as threatening as he once was. You can make a decent case of Evilswarm, but again, Konami isn't likely to kill him as he solves problems and is easily removed from the field, same with Number 101 (101 is cool, but basically a better version of Maestroke the Symphony Djinn and a once-time protection isn't that big a deal). As for BLS, he hasn't been seeing a ton of use as of late, maybe in Shadolls, but that's it. Also, making people rage-quit isn't a reason to ban a card. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 02:06, May 28, 2014 (UTC)

Here's My Predictions:

Banned: -Dark Hole:Speaks For Itself

-Solemn Warning:I think this is the most used Trap now,yeah it's 2000 LP but you can negate anything,also the Normal Summon of an annoying card like Yamato,So I think it'll reach it's big bro Solemn Judgment in July.

-Blaster,Redox,Tempest,Tidal:When Konami put them to 1 I thought they were dead,Now I realize the only way to get rid of this Deck and all is variants is banning all 4 Dragons.


Limited: -Bujingi Crane:Why does Bujin need to have 7 Honests,while all other Decks have 1???

-Abyssteus/Abyssphere:I think at least one of these 2 cards needs to be limited,not Gunde,again why did they limit Abyssgunde?? Pointless...

-Fire Formation-Tenki:I know Konami wants to promote Bujin (See PRIO TCG Exclusive) but this card is basically ROTA for Beast-Warriors,it's used by tons of Decks,some of which are also Top Tiers,Imo it should have been limited already in January...

-Madolche Hootcake:My poor lil' harmless Hootcake :( Being a Madolche player I'd like this card to be left untouched,but it's clear that with the release of Anjelly,Madolches got a boost,and it's also clear that Hootcake has always been the problem,now with Anjelly it's just way too easy to use and reuse him,So if Madolche starts to do well,I think this card will be the first one to be hit.

-Dark Magician Of Chaos:Now the only Deck that could "Abuse" of this card is Spellbook,so I don't see why it should stay banned,now it's far less dangerous than it was before.

-Trishula,Dragon Of The Ice Barrier:Yeah I know this card is kinda OP but hwo many Decks can consistenly drop it? The game now is dominated by Xyz-Based Decks so I don't think limiting this card again will have this huge impact,in OCG it's limited since September and nobody has died cause of it...

-Cold Wave:Why can't I OTK without being stalked by a Trap everytime I activate an effect??? With the release of Artifacts it's clear that Heavy can't come back and Giant Trunade would make Fiendish Chains and COTH recyclable so it won't come back too,but I'm tired seeing my Summons negated or my Beelze killed by Dimensional Prison,I want a card to OTK in peace! (I know Konami doesn't care of what I think but...)

-Number 101-Silent Honors ARK:Maybe it won't happen in July but I think this card is more "List Worthy" than Exciton,nobody runs 2 Excitons while this card is spammed in every Deck,have you ever played against Heraldic Beasts? They and they're not the only Deck have more than 1 copy of this card so I think it deserves to be limited... Ive Played With Heraldic Beasts And Summoned 3 101s And Absorbed His 3rd 101 Lol That Was 2 Awesome.Socialgames (talk • contribs) 12:25, June 10, 2014 (UTC)

-Artifact Sanctum:"If you activate this card you cannot conduct your Battle Phase" tell me who has ever used this card in their turn! I simply hate this card,your quietly conducting your turn and all at once they use this thing and pop Moralltach or Schyte to screw up your plays...

Semi-Limited

-Honest:I know this may seem absurd,but Artifacts are Light and also Lightsworns are getting new support so maybe Konami could put this to 2 to promote them...

-Dark Armed Dragon:Don't think this card would have a huge impact on the game even if it was Semi....

Thunder King Rai-Oh:C'mon we need a way to stop Bujins and Fire Fist from searching their entire Decks... And then I still don't understand why this card was limited -.-

And that's all for my kinda butthurt predictions on how much I hate this Format :)

Prudence94 (talk • contribs) 08:36, May 28, 2014 (UTC)

Warning doesn't have to be banned, it negates a summon for a couple thousand life points, which is good, but not enough to ban it. Judgment negates anything and can always be afforded no matter what. Tenki and ROTA can both be at 2 to give good support to their respective types without being too strong. Cold Wave, "Why can't I OTK without being stalked by a Trap everytime I activate an effect???". Because OTK's are bad for the game; they promote one-player games, and yugioh is supposed to be a two-player game where both players interact with one another, not a one-player game where you play all you want and your opponent can't do anything to stop you. I personally dislike Trishula, although it realistically could come back. Honest won't come down from 1, especially if you're advocating for Crane to get hit; if anything Honest should go to 0. The rest I agree with, to some extent. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 21:33, May 28, 2014 (UTC)
"Why can't I OTK without being stalked by a Trap...?" Hey, have you tried Trap Stun? --Gadjiltron (talk • contribs) 16:47, May 29, 2014 (UTC)
I think we'll see Heavy back before we see Cold Wave (artifacts don't prevent Heavy from coming back, it's actually an argument IN FAVOR of bringing it back). Trish may not be as threatening as before, but many decks (like Agents) are still fully capable of making it without greatly changing your build (unlike Quasar which requires a deck to be built around it). Holmez89 (talk • contribs) 16:13, June 6, 2014 (UTC)

Dude, you forget about "The Transmigration Prophecy". This card can get off the lists as this card and the loop is way too slow nowadays. Sui cho (talk • contribs) 23:31, May 28, 2014 (UTC)

It could come off, but the fact that the OCG has a habit of creating Stall Decks with it doesn't help it's case. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 03:39, May 29, 2014 (UTC)

GalaxytechDarklord's Predictions

While every prediction has a certain degree of bias towards each of the choices I have tried to fairly justify my predictions (see below list).

Banned: 

- Coach Soldier Wolfbark
- Rekindling

Limited: 

- The World of Prophecy
- Soul Charge
- Bujingi Crane
- Abyss Sphere/Mermail Abyssteus
- Madolche Anjelly
- Fire Formation Tenki/Gyokkou
- Sangan
- Dragon Ravine
- Return from the Different Dimension
- Elemental HERO Stratos

Semi Limited: 

- Infernity Launcher (While Barrier remains at 1)
- Super Rejuvenation

Unlimited: 

- Infernity Barrier
- Morphing Jar #2
- Magician of Faith
- Dark Strike Fighter
- The Transmigration Prophecy

Explanations:

For my Banned predictions I attacked Coach Soldier Wolfbark and Rekindling; two very powerful cards in the right place. People were happy after they were put to one in April but the truth is all the people who ran them only really ran 1 of both anyway because in the wrong situation they clog. With Fire Fists raging on something has to give.

For Limited I chose some cards that are overpowering to the game.

Firstly, The World of Prophecy. Spellbooks were most probably a product of one of Konami's theories to stir up the meta, "I wonder what happens when we invent an archetype of spell cards..." not only did they speed up the meta with Spellbooks but the high-level monsters were ridiculously easy to summon and, not only that, but The World of Prophecy can completely obliterate the field on summoning. Yes, you may be thinking "But Spellbook of Judgement was a greater threat that any of the monsters..." Answer: Yes and no, while a overpowered card, it was never properly integrated into the meta since it was hit a couple of weeks after its release.

Secondly I chose Soul Charge. A powerful staple for any competitive play. Go to your locals without one and your a nobody...Just kidding... but seriously while it is more balanced than monster reborn at 3 tier 1 deck will run wild with this card.

Thirdly, Bujingi Crane, Honest for Bujins. With the release of Primal Origin Bujins have received far more support than they should have, with their initial release in Judgement of the Light they were packed with more than enough juice to make a mockery of every deck in tier 2 and most of the stuff in tier 1. Just like Honest and Kalut, Crane should be limited for now...

I then turned to Mermails, very op with their recent releases. Very annoying as well. Abyss Sphere causes a lot of this stuff and Mermail Abyssteus causes a lot of problems as well. In my opinion one of these has to budge.

I think it’s obvious why I chose Madolche Anjelly: it allows the archetype to run wild even further than they already have.

Next on the hitlist; Fire Formation Tenki/Gyokkou. One of these two has to budge because they tend to be the opening card for Fire Fists and, while this may not apply to Gyokkou, Tenki has a wide generic range making it useable in Bujins, Gladiator Beasts and other various archetypes. Tensu can be mildly annoying also, having the backrow sealing ability makes it cloggy at times but when used in the perfect situation it would be enough to push for game.

Something I feel about the next card angers me a lot: that’s right, Sangan. This is a card that should never have made it to the banned section in the first place. While Chaos Dragons manipulated it mildly and plain Exodia decks worshipped this card. It was never a card that would make a deck so overpowered it jumps from tier 3 to tier 1 and, with Chaos Dragons not doing so well these days it should go back to 1.

Dragon Ravine. At the time of its banning it was abused by Dragon Rulers and, consequently, Konami put their foot down. While they can’t admit that the Dragon Rulers were way way way too OP banning Ravine caused a lot of anger especially with some guys at my locals who had been running pure Dragunity decks since day 1 of their initial release. With the Rulers being nothing more than tech support at this point Ravine should be slowly re-introduced.

Return From the Different Dimension: For the same reason as Dragon Ravine.

Elemental HERO Stratos was one of the only things that made E-HEROs good and caused angry riots among HERO players because of it. HEROs aren’t really threatening and Stratos was a staple to them.

For Semi-Limited I look at only 2 cards: Infernity Launcher and Super Rejuvenation. Launcher is one of the ace cards of Infernity decks and while the other, Infernity Barrier, is locked at 1 Launcher should come to support them still. As for Rejuvenation it was abused by Dragon Rulers but was the endgame card for Exodia Draw, not a threatening deck.

Unlimited: Infernity Barrier: An annoying card, yes, but necessary to allow Infernity decks to stay at tier 3 Morphing Jar #2: Shouldn’t be there, not sure why it is.

Magician of Faith: Not a widely used card, been on the banlist for too long, etc.

Dark Strike Fighter: Its effect has been re-written in Japan meaning it will be in the US/UK as well, probably, meaning it is a fair, balanced and generic Synchro.

The Transmigration Prophecy: not OP, not powerful, not a game-changer.

GalaxytechDarklord (talk • contribs) 12:49, June 2, 2014 (UTC)

People who ran Wolf and Rekindling ran a minimum of two, Wolf was usually run at 3 in Fire Fist and Rekindling was run at 2-3 in Fire Kings. Sangan can't come back, Tour Guide still searches him and Konami made it clear they don't want to deal with a general searcher; while I don't think he'll break the game, he just searches for way too much. Return from the Different Dimension can't come back, it's like Soul Charge, but you'll always be able to use it to summon 5 monsters, and Dragon Rulers are still a thing. Dragon Ravine, again, Rulers must leave the game before Dragunity can be brought back into the game, same with Rejuvenation.
Stratos was a very broken card if you look at it, I'm not saying HEROs shouldn't have a search card (They have like 6 Spells + Dark Mist later this year), but Stratos triggers no matter how he is summoned and is recycled with Shining. Morphing Jar #2 is banned because it is part of a First Turn Kill with Creature Swap and Jackpot 7, even though the FTK isn't easy to do, Konami hates FTKs (Not necessarily true of OTKs), because they kinda just ruin the game. DSF will probably be dropped on the list as his database text has been updated as well. Transmigration can loop itself, while it isn't game-breaking, it's part of stall decks with D.D. Borderline.

--Dark Ace SP (Talk) 13:05, June 2, 2014 (UTC)

You're wrong on Wolfbark and Rekindling, every 4-axis Fire Fist player and Fire King player ran 3 Wolfbark when it was at 3, and 3-axis Fire Fists and Fire Kings ran at least 2 Rekindlings (Laval Quasar ran 3). Although, I do want Rekindling banned because it's terribly designed, but Wolfbark can stay at 1, like Fire Fist Spirit.

As for the limited cards...Prophecies are fine where they're at and limiting World won't do much as most players that run World don't run more than 1 (since World at more than 1 can lead to dead hands, it's useless if it's not in your deck to Temperance it, or grave to life it). Soul Charge, Bujingi Crane, and Abysteus/Sphere at 1 are good; Soul Charge is strong but not good enough to be outright banned, Crane to 1 is the best way to hit Bujins (Yamato to 1 would kill the deck), and Gunde to 1 didn't really change things in Mermails, Teus or Sphere should've been hit instead. Anjelly is not the problem with Madolches, Hootcake is the card you need to hit since he's the one that opens up the easy OTK plays in the deck by summoning Messengelato straight from your deck, then overlaying it and Mewfeuille to make MX Saber or Leviair, summon another Messen or revive Anjelly, then go into Tiaramisu to bounce off their field and go for the kill. Fire Fists are fine with 1 Spirit and 1 Wolfbark; Tenki and Gyokkou don't need to go to 1 (though Tenki could go to 2 as a slight check to them and Bujins). Sangan is a universal searcher that's searchable and recyclable through Tour Guide and Crane Crane, and Konami doesn't like universal searchers. The 4 dragon rulers have to be banned before Ravine can come back (since 1 Ravine becomes 4 with triple Terraforming, 5 if you count pseudo-space), and Return from the Different Dimension shouldn't come back even if the rulers get banned, it's a badly designed card that's used for nothing but OTK's. Rulers are also hardly techs; they still glue together Hieratics and Mythic Dragons as pure dragon decks, and allow them to top with the huge consistency they bring. Stratos is too strong to come back; it kept 4 other cards on the list at 1, and it caused too many OTK's with his lack of a OPT restriction and working on normal or special summon. If anything, give HERO's a 2nd or 3rd Reinforcement of the Army to help them instead.

Semi-limited...Launcher will never come down from 1, it causes loops and easy OTK's at more than 1, can be searched easily by Archfiend, and if anything I'd ban Launcher to allow Barrier to go back to 2-3. Rejuvenation, like Return from the Different Dimension, is badly designed without the Rulers, and we don't need another Exodia FTK card in the game.

Unlimited...Barrier can go to 3 only if you ban Launcher, Launcher is the only card that really needs to be hit out of the deck. Morphing Jar #2 is banned because of an FTK with the spell card Jackpot 7; you set MJ2, use creature swap, then attack it, and use Morphing Jar 2's effect (under your opponent's possession) to mill through your entire deck of spell cards and the 3 milled Jackpot 7's will win you the duel. I agree with Faith, it's a slow and bad card and no one would notice if it went to 3 or not; besides, all the broken, staple-esque spells are banned or limited. Dark Strike, when the TCG eventually gets it's OPT errata like the OCG did, then yes, it can come down to 3. Transmigration loops itself at more than 1 and causes a nasty stall deck with D.D. Borderline at more than 1.

That's my comments. Some of them make sense, but others, not quite. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 15:42, June 2, 2014 (UTC)

SM10's Thoughts

Banned:

  • Royal Tribute (1 of those "instant win" cards Konami now hates, such as RftDD or Rekindling, and Sams don't get Gateway, so GK's shouldn't have this)

Limited:

Semi-Limited:

Unlimited:

Not Likely, Just My Opinion

  • Metamorphosis to 1 (not likely to happen, but the card has little use outside of a few decks, but Hieratics or Destiny HERO - Malicious can get a 1-for-1 Ryu Senshi, Artifact decks can trade an Artifact for Dark Balter the Terrible, and Dragon Rulers can trade a Ruler for The Last Warrior from Another Planet. Chaos Dragons can summon Dark Balter or Ryu Senshi off of Darkflare Dragon or Lightpulsar Dragon, respectively, and can even drop Naturia Exterio or Gaia Drake, the Universal Force with REDMD or Tragoedia. Cool stuff, would be a neat format to see.)
  • Heavy Storm/Giant Trunade to 1 (1 of these NEEDS to come back because they are necessary to a healthy game state, in my opinion. It leads to really slow formats, rather than balanced ones, and allows for careless overextension of backrow. Artifacts punish Heavy Storm as well now, so it's not as powerful as it once was. The existence of so many just good removal traps shows how important a mass S/T removal card is. Please bring one of them back, preferably Heavy Storm, Konami, and fix some of the traps on the list.
  • Glow-Up Bulb to 1 (literally makes everything better, and although some decks may easily abuse Bulb more than others and the card has not changed, the environment has evolved, including more ways to deal with Quasar and other Synchro power plays.)
  • Gorz the Emissary of Darkness to 2 (great card, can be dead at times, but it's one of the few cards remaining that can dig a player out of a tough situation and isn't really overpowered, although probably still wouldn't see much use at 2 outside of Frogs and such.)

That is all. Thanks. Synchro Maniac10 (talk • contribs) 16:00, June 2, 2014 (UTC)

Geargiarmor doesn't need a hit if Geargiagear goes to 1. Skill Drain is designed in such a way that it can't define a format, because most decks need the graveyard more than they need the field. That's why the 3 grave floodgates (Macro, Fissure, Soul Drain) are limited and Skill Drain won't be. Zenmaity can come back even if Shark doesn't get hit; Wind-Ups could use a little love. Sams still top some regionals from time to time, and triple Shi-En would definitely make people pick them up again for competitive YCS's, ect. T.G. Hyper Librarian will not come down from 1, because if it does then it becomes a free Pot of Greed every time either player synchro summons. If anything T.G. Hyper should go to 0 so Formula can come down to 2-3 with no serious issues. Lastly, Sanctum to 2 isn't nearly enough; to 1 would be better. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 17:51, June 2, 2014 (UTC)
Geargia have always been a deck that tops YCS's since its inception, even before Geargiagear existed. The deck could still use an additional hit, especially when Geargiauger becomes a thing, if not now.
You really don't make a good argument or explanation for Skill Drain...like I think you're missing the point. It has become similar to Royal Oppression before its ban in that it can be used to keep the opponent completely locked out of the game when they would otherwise have several options. In fact, Skill Drain is a huge reason why Mythic Rulers are still so effective. After they establish their set-up, they can protect their field with Stardust and beat down with the Rulers. Skill Drain cripples more decks than you realize - pure Geargia can't search anything at all, and even if the Geargia player has a Geargiaccel, all of the Rank 4's can do nothing about Skill Drain and lose their effects, but Geargia doesn't care about Macro, Fissure, or Soul Drain at all. Madolche can't use swarm with Hootcake or Mew-feuille , or search with Magileine and Messengelato, resorting them to a grind game that they may pull off with enough traps and Chateau in play. Infernities literally can't function under Skill Drain, as they hinge on searches off of Infernity Archfiend and summons from Infernity Necromancer. Evilswarm lose all of their control effects and their easy access to Rank 4 plays, and Ophion can not lock down cards like the Rulers under Skill Drain, so the only hope they have is to make an awkward play with Evilswarm Exciton Knight and Infestation Pandemic if they can't get rid of Drain otherwise. And finally, HATs, or Traptrix Artifact Hands, lose 2/3 of their engines. Artifacts may be hard countered more-so by Soul Drain, but they lose their bite because the Artifacts need their on-field effects to disrupt the opponent's plays. Traptrix are basically weak Vanillas under Skill Drain, which leaves HATs to depend on drawing the Hands to regain control of the game and pop Skill Drain. Even Dragon Rulers can lose to a well-timed Skill Drain before they finish setting up, so all of the top decks this format are affected by Skill Drain in some way, with a large portion of them being crippled. It's been at 1, 2, and 3 depending on the format, and I think it's time for it to go back on the list now more than ever, especially with Heavy Storm banned and MST quickly on the decline with the threat of Artifacts. That is my reasoning behind limiting Skill Drain.
We don't really want a repeat of Wind-Ups again, so 2 Shark makes Magician + Shark a little less consistent, but really it could probably stay at 3. Shi En is raped by Dragon Rulers, Hands, any 1 monster Rank 4 play (Geargiarmor, Traptrix Dionaea, etc.) and is much easier to play around in the game now. Correction on Librarian: two of them become a free Pot of Greed every time either player Synchro Summons. Now tell me, what viable deck can abuse that and easily put 2 Librarians on the board in one turn without wasting too many resources? I'm hard-pressed to think of one now because it's just not as likely anymore. Sanctum is not likely to go to 1 just yet until Konami gives time for Artifacts to shake out, much like Fire Fists, but it appears that is not too excessive by any means. Unfortunately, even Sanctum to 2 is actually just a really hopeful hit. Synchro Maniac10 (talk • contribs) 21:48, June 2, 2014 (UTC)
Yeah, considering Konami just released Artifacts for the TCG, Sanctum might go off easy on the July list and instead get hit the list after. As for Skill Drain...again, it's designed in such a way as to where it can't define or win an entire format on it's own, because it punishes you just as much as your opponent. The Dragon Rulers are terrible design on their own and need to be banned, Artifacts can blow up Skill Drain with Ice Hand or Artifact Ignition (or Malevolent Catastrophe/Double Cyclone, if you run more of a pure build), Madolches and Geargias can shut it down with Trap Stun (then OTK that turn), Infernities can blow it up with Break...the card just has a lot of ways to easily be played around, and I know this because if Skill Drain wasn't easily played around, or was hard to counter, then Skill Drain decks would be everywhere and would literally define the entire format, like Oppression did back in March 2011...but they aren't and don't. As for Geargias...if you really wanted to give them another hit on top of Geargiagear, smack Accelerator instead of Armor.
Wind-Ups won't return to their former tier-broken glory with 1 Zenmaity and 1 Magician, it'll allow them to be a fun tier 2 deck again at best, but without Avarice they can't hand loop, without Shock Master they can't control the field and OTK, and with only 1 Magician they have limited swarm options (oh and Sangan is also gone, limiting their searchability a little bit). They'll need a lot more than 1 Zenmaity and 1 Magician to be propelled to tier 1 again. The only reason sams don't drop double shi-en turn 1 and then set 3-4 backrow (drawn into from united), is because Shi-en is at 1, and they can quite easily drop 2 shi-ens turn 1 with all the search and tutor power they have. And truth be told, there are quite a lot of decks today that rely on S/T's to get their plays going. Artifacts need S/T's to summon themselves, Madolches can't use ticket or chateau, Geargias can't use Geargiagear or their other traps, Fire Fists can't use their Tenki's, Bujins and Mermails...eh, I'll give you them, but Crane is being hit soon enough and Mermails need a different hit anyways. If anything, bring ROTA down to 2-3 to boost them. ROTA to 2-3 would also help HERO's out quite a bit, and they need all the help they can get with Stratos banned. Additionally, unlimiting ROTA would also help promote satellaknights, coming out later this year. I don't care about consistency with things like Hyper Librarian, in fact the truth is it can still be made consistently in synchrocentric decks; they've just fallen victim to the xyz power creep that has taken over this game over the past few years (like Sams, somewhat), and if you want to give synchros new support, unlimiting a generic lv 5 synchro that rewards over-extension for free isn't a good way to do it. Formula can come down to 2-3 as long as the broken lv 1 tuners stay banned, but Librarian if anything needs to go to 0, it rewards you for recklessly using up all of your resources, like Super Rejuvenation or Spellbook of Judgment, both of which are also banned. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 22:51, June 2, 2014 (UTC)

Jetian's thoughts

  • Banned:
    • Dragon Rulers - alright, they are very difficult, but can be a big threat for anyone. Besides, their "pre-evolved" forms are banned, so why not a their "older" forms?
    • Brotherhood of Fire Fist - Gorilla and Bear - this pair is especially pain in duelists, who prefer a cards, where requirements are important.
  • Limited:
    • Archlord Kristya
    • Morphing Jar 1 and 2
    • Bujingi Crane
    • Monster Reborn
    • Master Hyperion[[
    • Fire Formation - Tenki
    • Light and Darkness Dragon
    • Wind-Up Zenmaines
    • Return from the Different Dimension
    • Macro Cosmos
  • Semi-Limited:
    • Neo-Spacian Grand Mole
    • Dark Strike Fighter
    • Red-Eyes Darkness Metal Dragon
  • Unlimited:
    • Dimension Fusion
    • Future Fusion
    • Formula Synchron

--Neo Razora 16:05, June 2, 2014 (UTC)

Future Fusion can not EVER go to 3. Chaos Dragons, especially with 2 Red-Eyes and Elemental HERO Synchro would literally dominate. The issue I have with Grand Mole is how well Stun decks can use it to maintain board control when they are already locking the opponent down. Fire Fists have been hit enough to where they're not as big of a threat anymore, so a hit Bear, Gorilla, and/or Tenki is unnecessary. The Jars just got hit; they have broken combos. Return from the Different Dimension at 1 would be "fair", but not now since Rekindling got hit. Reborn could come back if Soul Charge got banned. Dimension Fusion is 10x more broken than Return, and will and should never come back. LaDD, Zenmaines, and Hyperion aren't even used that much anymore and don't deserve a hit. Macro is already at 1, and Kristya, while very powerful, is rarely seen outside of rogue strategies. Crane and Formula are fine where you have them, and Dark Strike can be at any number once it is errata'd. Hope all of that makes sense. Synchro Maniac10 (talk • contribs) 16:23, June 2, 2014 (UTC)

Dimension Fusion and Future Fusion to 3, AND REDMD to 2? You must be one hardcore Chaos Dragon player...Oh and BTW, Macro is already limited. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 17:54, June 2, 2014 (UTC)
Again, the Jars are part of a FTK kill, and while you can argue that Exodia is also an FTK. Konami has chosen to deal with a FTK and we should let them. Not saying Exodia gets a pass for being a potential FTK, just that when Konami decides to kill an FTK deck, we should allow them to do so. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 02:09, June 3, 2014 (UTC)

My ban list predictions: These would balance out the game, but I don't know what Konami will do and if they will hit the new cards just yet. This would also give old decks a chance as well.

  • Banned:
    • All 4 Dragon rulers: It is time to kill them. Many banned/limited cards can come back if they're gone, just like Stratos.
    • Wind-Up Hunter: Take the OCG route, ban Hunter and bring back Zenmaity.
  • Limited:
    • Cyber-Stein: Extremely high cost, and if it is hit with Effect Veiler, it is almost always a loss for that game. Dealing with Naturia Exterio is as easy as summoning Brotherhood of the Fire Fist - Bear, Evilswarm Exciton Knight, Number 101, Breakthrough Skill from grave effect, Fire or Ice Hand, Moralltach, activating Artifact Sanctum and having it be negated and destroyed and then using its second effect to pop Exterio, or just attacking over it by battle.
    • Madolche Hootcake: Some people are saying that Anjelly is the problem, it isn't. Hootcake (and to an extent Ticket) are. They are the OTK cards. Anjelly just searches Hootcake. If Hootcake is limited, the deck will lose much of its OTK potential and it will likely go back to control based, which it was designed for in the first place.
    • Sinister Serpent: Many reasons have been suggested why this card is banned, but none of them make sense. The card is too slow and if it is limited, the opponent can just D.D. crow it and be done with it (which some decks are siding for artifacts).
    • Tribe-Infecting Virus: It takes up a Normal Summon, and won't be used in the current metagame, except maybe for Mermails, but that is debatable.
    • Goyo Guardian: A good point was made about this card. The only decks that really synchro summon this format is Blackwings, Agents, Six Samurai, and Infernity to some extent (not the XYZ variant, the synchro variant, and these decks aren't relevant this format. (3 Axis Fire Fist can't synchro Spirit and Leopard or another card since Spirit states that it must be used for a Beast Warrior Synchro.) Big Eye is also a card that is way better then this card. Konami could bring this card back. This is a very controversial card, but it could allow Synchro decks to get their own mini Big Eye card.
    • Trishula, Dragon of the Ice Barrier: This card hasn't seen much competitive play in Japan, and if this card came back here, the only decks that could use it effectively would be Agents and Six Samurai, and those decks could use a boost.
    • Wind-Up Carrier Zenmaity: With Hunter banned, this card could come back.
    • Dragon Ravine (Dragons dead, bring back Dragunity).
    • Kaiser Colosseum: One of those "You can't play Yugioh" cards.
    • Soul Charge: Needs to be limited.
    • Artifact Sanctum: It speeds up the Artifact deck and has no downside whatsoever (except being a trap and not being a quick-play spell), and gets the Moralltach which pops any problematic card, or Beagalltach which generates more advantage.
    • Geargiagear: Sets up plays, sets up advantage.
  • Semi Limited:
    • Blackwing - Gale the Whirlwind: Blackwings haven't done anything even with 3 Whirlwind and Black Sonic.
    • Dark Armed Dragon: Give DARK decks a boost.
    • Fire Hand/Ice Hand: Either that, or limit them. They are way too powerful, allowing you to destroy your opponent's field with minimal drawbacks.
    • Gladiator Beast Bestiari: Gladiator Beasts haven't been doing anything, even in Japan with 3 Bestiari.
    • Gorz the Emissary of Darkness: With the huge trap lineups and continuous Spell/Traps, most decks won't even be able to summon this card.
    • Magician of Faith: No one used her at 1, they probably won't at 2.
    • Neo-Spacian Grand Mole: Mostly just a troll card, but can easily be destroyed. Not used in the meta at all.
    • Legendary Six Samurai - Shi En: Six Samurais are horrible with Fire and Ice Hands running around, and Bear, Moralltach, Big Eye, etc. to get rid of the player's only Shi En. If Six Samurais lose their Shi En, they usually lose that game. They can use another copy of Shi En.
  • Unlimited:
    • Debris Dragon: With the dragon rulers banned, this could come back.
    • Reborn Tengu: It hasn't been played really competitively since it got semi limited, and it can help combat the Hands.
    • Advanced Ritual Art: In support for the new ritual cards in Duelist Alliance.
    • Chain Strike: Burn hasn't done anything.
    • Reasoning: Dark Magician of Chaos and Return from the Different Dimension are banned.
    • Sacred Sword of Seven Stars: Dragons are dead per this list.
    • Super Rejuvenation: See above.
    • Gold Sarcophagus: ^
    • All 4 Baby Dragon Rulers: Pointless now that the big dragons are banned per this list, so these can go back to 3.
    • Mirror Force: No one is using this card anymore because of the Hands.
    • The Transmigration Prophecy: Similar to Sinister Serpent, there are some reasons given why this card has to be limited, such as it recycles and you never deck out, but Bait Doll is a card that also does that, and so is the entire Madolche archetype. As for stall, stall decks are bad and irrelevant.
    • Wall of Revealing Light: Self Destruct Button is banned, so this card is just another stall card that can be blown up with MST, but at least with Swords of Revealing Light, it can't be negated by Royal Decree, and you keep your Life Points if it's negated. If you want to get rid of your Life Points, Inspection also lets you pay almost any number of Life Points essentially. Red demon dragon (talk • contribs) 06:13, June 3, 2014 (UTC)
Wind-Up Carrier Zenmaity could come back to 1 regardless of Hunter's status, because the hand loop is impossible in the TCG with Avarice banned; also Shock Master is banned and Magician is at 1, making it nearly imposible for them to OTK, if at all. Cyber-Stein is banned because it's not really used for anything other than OTK's or lockdowns. It's not just Exterio, Last Warrior is also a thing, which prevents all summons, and you can make an FTK with Stein by using it with DNA Surgery (calling psychic-type), then Brain Research Lab to swarm your field with fusions at no cost. Oh and Gear Gigant X can search it easily. Kaiser Colosseum doesn't need to be hit; in fact it's fallen out of popularity a lot recently, even in Bujins, because Vanity's Emptiness is better most of the time, and that is also pretty easy to play around. Magician of Faith could even go to 3, it's just not good anymore. Fire Hand and Ice hand are quite balanced, since they can only summon themselves from your deck, and drawing into all of them sucks. Chain Burn does still make the top 32 at regionals and YCS from time to time, they don't need a 3rd Chain Strike, and Super Rejuvenation is also banned due to dragon draw exodia FTK, not just abuse from the rulers. I'm really not sure on Goyo and Trishula, but I'd rather leave them banned and make balanced replacements of them. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 11:31, June 3, 2014 (UTC)
Shi-En can't come back to two. It's entirely possible and consistent for a Sam Duelist to get two of these out in one turn. Having two Shi Ens is just game breaking for most decks, even in today's game. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 03:50, June 6, 2014 (UTC)

My Prediction

Banned

Absorbing Jar

Dice Jar

Dark Hole* (if Heavy Storm stays banned)

Limited

Abyss-sphere

Madolche Angelly

Soul Charge

Evilswarm Ophion

Artifact Sanctum

Heavy Storm* (if Dark Hole stays unbanned)

Kuribandit

Fire Formation - Tenki

Traptrix Dionaea

Bujingi Crane

Geargiagear

Hysteric Party

Judgment Dragon

Black Whirlwind

Semi-Limited

Harpies' Hunting Ground

Infestation Pandemic

Bujin Yamato

Traptrix Myrmeleo

Madolche Hootcake

Artifact Ignition

Madolche Chateau

Madolche Ticket

Ice Hand

Fire Hand

Pot of Duality

Reckless Greed

Macro Cosmos* (if Banisher of the Radiance/Light stays unbanned)

Dimensional Fissure* (if Banisher of the Radiance/Light stays unbanned)

Royal Decree

Kaiser Colosseum Pwndkthnx (talk • contribs) 04:34, June 5, 2014 (UTC)

Dice Jar? Seriously? Did you get pwned by someone rolling a 6 on you? --Gadjiltron (talk • contribs) 11:34, June 5, 2014 (UTC)
I don't think you can successfully compare Heavy Storm and Dark Hole. Dark Hole only kills monsters, and it's easier to recover from losing two monsters than it is from losing 2-3 Spell/Traps. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 12:36, June 5, 2014 (UTC)
Wow.........there are alot of things there that i personally want to see. unfortunately, will more then likely not happen. Most players run 2 of the hands anyway (or so i am told, i run 3 of each in a hunder deck because i really like opening with a seahorse and a hand to set) If Artifacts were't a think i would be laughing at teh absorbing jar, but Dice jar? pls don't tell you think that will be hit because the Morphing Jars were. too soon to hit Sanctum or ignition.DreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 21:57, June 5, 2014 (UTC)

If you just put down Absorbing Jar and Dice Jar because Konami just banned Morphing Jars 1 and 2, I can't take you seriously. They won't just randomly ban all the jars. Also, most of the other cards are unnecessary. My comments on each?

Banned

  • Absorbing Jar - Read above. Konami didn't just randomly ban the Morphing Jars, they were part of an FTK with Jackpot 7 and were justified. This and Dice Jar? You've got to be kidding me.
  • Dice Jar - ^^
  • Dark Hole* (if Heavy Storm stays banned) - Meh, I won't care if it goes.

Limited

  • Abyss-sphere - Sure.
  • Madolche Angelly - No, limit Hootcake.
  • Soul Charge - Agreed.
  • Evilswarm Ophion - Eh...Evilswarms aren't too good with Xyz Encore to easily take care of Ophion and I would much rather them limit Kerykeion or Pandemic instead of this.
  • Artifact Sanctum - Agreed.
  • Heavy Storm* (if Dark Hole stays unbanned) - No, we don't want this back in the game, backrow is harder to recover than monsters and the backrow and alternate S/T removal is balanced as it is now.
  • Kuribandit - My god, did you just lose to this? No way, it's a blind mill card that's nothing more than a decent tech for some graveyard-reliant decks.
  • Fire Formation - Tenki - Eh, it could get slapped to 2 again, but to 1 is too harsh.
  • Traptrix Dionaea - Nope.
  • Bujingi Crane - This and Tenki to 2 is the best way to hit Bujins without killing them.
  • Geargiagear - Agreed.
  • Hysteric Party - Could see it happening someday, but Harpies don't do much right now.
  • Judgment Dragon - Could actually get banned eventually, I won't care as the deck sucks either way.
  • Black Whirlwind - Why do you want to punish Blackwings? What have they done in the past 5-6 months to warrant a hit?

Semi-Limited

  • Harpies' Hunting Ground - Nope.
  • Infestation Pandemic - Most people only run 2 anyways...
  • Bujin Yamato - No, limit Crane, maybe semi Tenki. But they need this at 3 to be a deck.
  • Traptrix Myrmeleo - Nope, most people only run 2 at most anyways.
  • Madolche Hootcake - To 1, and leave Anjelly alone.
  • Artifact Ignition - Sanctum to 1 is enough.
  • Madolche Chateau - No one runs more than 2...
  • Madolche Ticket - ^
  • Ice Hand - ^^
  • Fire Hand - ^^^
  • Pot of Duality - ^^^^
  • Reckless Greed - Nope.
  • Macro Cosmos* (if Banisher of the Radiance/Light stays unbanned) - No, too many decks need the grave right now, this, D-Fissure, and Soul Drain are floodgates that shut down nearly 90% of all decks at the moment. They will stay at 1.
  • Dimensional Fissure* (if Banisher of the Radiance/Light stays unbanned) - ^
  • Royal Decree - It's a balanced way to play around traps, leave it at 3.
  • Kaiser Colosseum - Again, no one runs more than 2.

Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 01:58, June 6, 2014 (UTC)

Also, another thing that differentiates the Monster Banishers form their Spell/Trap cousins is that the monsters can be negated via Breakthrough Skill and are very weak and their easy to run over. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 03:46, June 6, 2014 (UTC)

BAN

All Dragon Rulers

WU hunter

LIMIT

Soul Charge

Ice/fire hand

geargiaccelerator

Bujin Crane

Artifact Sanctum

WU Zenmaighty

SEMI

Skill Drain

BW Gale

Gorz

Gold Sarc

Grand Mole

UNLIMIT

Magician of faith

GB Bestiari

Baby rulers

Notable cards : "Sinister Serpent" (how can this card even affect the meta?), "Dragon Ravine" (With Rulers gone dragunities need some help) , "Vanity's emptiness" (well,it could be hit but i don't see that happening - maybe semi) Tupac1971ful (talk • contribs) 21:24, June 8, 2014 (UTC)

Typically, people want an effect with as few drawbacks as possible (why pay 2000 LP or discard a card if another has the same, or similar, effect for no cost?). SS makes discard costs "free" (it would allow for more variation, but inherently removes a balancing feature). Holmez89 (talk • contribs) 22:02, June 8, 2014 (UTC)
There's a risk that Foolish, Mathematician, and Lavalval Chain could be used quickly to set him up, I agree with that. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 15:21, June 9, 2014 (UTC)

Moja619's Predictions

This list is rather long.


Forbidden

All 4 senior Dragon Rulers - though they are not currently OP at one, Konami had to hit several other cards just to keep these 4 from becoming too strong even at 1. The best option is to ban them

Dark Hole - time to ban the last of the "Big 3"


Limited

Sinister Serpent - i still think it's worth experimenting at 1

Pot of Avarice - just because Pot of Dichotomy exists in ths TCG doesn't mean that Avarice should get banned

Super Rejuvenation - if the 4 senior rulers get banned

Fire Formation - Tenki - bujins and fire fists were topping thanks in part to this card

Mermail Abyssteus - should have gotten hit insteada of Gunde

Traptrix Myrmeleo - HAT decks should receive a hit, but all the core cards are relatively new. the only candidate that's left is Myrmeleo

Geargiagear - easy xyz summon. geargias are currently topping thanks to this card

Madolche Hootcake - because anjelly is too new to get hit


Semi-Limited

Dragon Ravine - if the 4 senior rulers get banned (hell, it should be unlimited)

Coach Soldier Wolfbark - if Tenki is limited

Debris Dragon - if the 4 senior rulers get banned

Genex Ally Birdman - i don't see why it's limited. i'm sure it'll do no harm at 2, and the Harpie Dancer OTk won't be possible at 2 also

Inzektor Dragonfly - just to see how inzektors fare with this move

Thunder King Rai-Oh - it's an anti-meta card, it shouldn't be at 1

Divine Wind of Mist Valley - similar to Birdman. Harpie Dancer OTK seems too inconsistent anyway

Bujingi Crane - honest for bujins. hell, it should even be limited


Unlimited

all 4 junior Dragon Rulers - if the 4 senior rulers get banned

Magician of Faith - nobody will run this card at 3

Wind-Up Magician - as long as zenmaighty stays banned, i think this card can come off the list

Gold Sarcophagus - if the 4 senior rulers get banned

Sacred Sword of Seven Stars - if the 4 senior rulers get banned

Advanced Ritual Art - nobody uses this anymore

Hieratic Seal of Convocation - if the 4 senior rulers get banned

Mermail Abyssgunde - if Abyssteus gets limited


Well, there's my list for the upcoming format. --Moja619 (talk • contribs) 02:40, June 9, 2014 (UTC)

Looks good, but I have a few criticisms:

  • Pot of Avarice - It shouldn't come back. Not only is Dichotomy a fair replacement of it, but it rewards over-extension by giving you fast, instant recovery if your monsters die. And it's basically Pot of Greed.
  • Tenki - Wolfbark should stay at 1 and Tenki should go to 2 instead, where it belonged. Oh and ROTA can come down to 2 with it, since warrior decks in general aren't good anymore.
  • Myrmeleo - HAT decks are amongst the best decks of the format, but they're actually quite a balanced deck and don't need to be hit right now. The most unbalanced card in the deck by far is Artifact Sanctum, but like you said they'll probably save that hit until after worlds.
  • Birdman and Divine Wind - I thought it would be also, but actually, the Harpie Dancer FTK is still possible with 1 of each, it's just less consistent, so I think they'll keep them at 1.
  • Inzektor Dragonfly - Inzektors still make the top 32 at regionals/YCS quite often, they don't need a boost.
  • Crane - To 1, semi won't cut it.
  • Wind-Up Magician - It loops itself at more than 1 with Shark to make 3-4 xyz's in one turn off of just two cards in your hand (Magician + Shark). If anything, bring Zenmaity back at 1 with Magician at 1 (and Avarice staying banned), so the deck can get a little better, but still not be broken.

That's all I have to say. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 12:27, June 9, 2014 (UTC)

Digglett33 predictions

(please note this is a prediction on what konami is likely to ban not what needs to be banned)

Banned

Limited

  • Soul Charge
    • Soul charge allows certain decks to set up unbreakable fields to the point of not caring about 5k life points. One example is a dragon ruler paying 4k and ending with 2 dracosacks on the first turn. At one it allows it to remain a power card that has to be used carefully and keeps infernities from falling off the face of the planet.
  • Thousand-Eyes Restrict
    • With Metamorphosis banned the only way to get this out is through instant fusion and at one makes it used sparingly and only in decks that can viably run instant fusion
  • Future Fusion
    • This pushes konami's agenda for selling Heros and Shadolls while also not being insane with the rulers being banned
  • Wind-Up Carrier Zenmaity
    • With Hunter Banned and shark at 2 this card coming back gives the deck to be at tier 2 while not being to perform insane loops, and has already been limited in the ocg and is doing nothing
  • Dragon Ravine
    • With rulers banned this card becomes reasonable at 1 and makes dragunities viable
  • Heavy Storm
    • As Konami creates more power traps and pushes OTK decks that use pendulums this card becomes a very reasonable possibility
  • Solemn Judgment
    • Heavy storm cannot live without solemn to be their to balance it and vice versa
  • Madolche Hootcake
    • With hootcake at one the deck is still viable as its recyclable but keeps plays from getting out of hand
  • Bujingi Crane
    • Makes bujins a reasonable deck that is still playable without stupid otks
  • Bad Reaction to Simochi
  • Nurse Reficule the Fallen One
    • Konami has shown that they don't like solitaire and burn decks which this card supports
  • Yata-Garasu
    • In a format with only one dark hole, dimensional prisons, and mirror forces yata becomes insanely hard to get off

Semi-Limited

Unlimited

Digglett33 (talk • contribs) 03:37, June 10, 2014 (UTC)Digglett3

Collapsed your lists into one so it's not as long and a little easier to read. Also,
OBJECTION!!
Yata explanation: "In a format with only one dark hole, dimensional prisons, and mirror forces..."
Mirror Force explanation: "It's a decent card but has seen no play at one and won't at three"
There's clearly a contradiction in his justification for Yata here. Not only does Yata dodge Dark Hole because it doesn't sit on the field long enough for the opponent to use a Normal Spell against it, but your claim that Mirror Force sees no play means that Mirror Force won't hinder Yata's effects.
Which means that D-Prison and its brethren are the only things checking Yata, but seriously, will anyone blindly attack with Yata while there's backrow out?
--Gadjiltron (talk • contribs) 05:28, June 10, 2014 (UTC)
I don't think Future Fusion needs to come back to push HEROs or Shadolls, they're kinda doing that on their own with their killer cards. Also, while Pot is a good card, it's much more effective to hit Artifact Sanctum or a key monster in that deck that hit Pot. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 13:24, June 10, 2014 (UTC)

Yata will never come back, it stops your opponent from drawing, which is part of playing the game (you said Konami doesn't like 1-player games), and counters don't justify it because when it's not countered you'll probably lose. And sorry, but the TCG won't reverse last September Heavy + the traps. They're staying put and won't change anytime soon. Also, Wind-Ups could probably get 1 Zenmaity back even with Hunter, since Avarice is banned and they can't use Dichotomy to loop since it's at the start of main phase 1. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 03:58, June 11, 2014 (UTC)

potential returners

these are cards I suspect konami may make return to us


im not saying I agree it otta come back


im saying konami might based on trends and past actions/new releases

  • CYBER-STEIN unbanned in japan. if negated you lose. most of the best fusions cant be summoned. fusion usually dies next turn w/o doing jack. can be mindcontroled/creatureswapped/bigeyed to get out our own fusion or better yet, just take the fusion and kill stein for game
  • DARK MAGICIAN OF CHAOS all the best magix are banned.
  • ELEMENTAL HERO STRATOS unbanned in jaPAN. only good wind hero. konami is pushin heroes
  • GLOW-UP BULB konami stopped hating synchroes so theres some chance
  • MAGICAL SCIENTIST if negated its a 300atk attack mode monster. best case scenario, burn through 6000 lp to get 3 xyz mons only to get dark holed and directed for game. basically a soul charge for the extra deck(which can only run 15 cards which limits most options)
  • MORPHING JAR unbanned in japan. easy to see coming
  • MORPHING JAR #2 unbanned in jAPAn
  • SINISTER SERPENT not a danger. few would run it. encourages bad deck building
  • TRIBE-INFECTING VIRUS not as good as it once was. effect often backfires. suicide in A MIRROR MATCH. usually its a 1 for 1 card to kill one monster.
  • THOUSAND-EYES RESTRICT nowhere near as op as it was a decade ago. no one would fuse monsters to poop it out. only instant fusion is easy to git r dun. stopping battle/mode change in no way protects it now with all the monster removal/effect negation. if it attacks, just chain and kill its equipped monster and it runs headfirst into a big monster with all of its 0 atk
  • DARK STRIKE FIGHTER errata made it playable
  • GOYO GUARDIAN big eye doesn't need to battle and can use xyz against opponents.
  • TRISHULA, DRAGON OF THE ICE BARRIER unbanned in japan. little use early game. harder to get out compared to the new synchros.
  • DRAGON RAVINE if rulers get nailed
  • GATEWAY OF THE SIX unbanned in japan. only thing making 6sam playable
  • HEAVY STORM with so many traps, chainables and artifacts its no where near as good as it was in the before time
  • METAMORPHOSIS best fusions cant be pooped out with this. fusion monster usually dies after a turn, assuming its doesn't just get bottemlessed or compulsaryed. fusion deck isn't as easy to slip in fusions as it was b4 synchro/xyz
  • MONSTER REBORN unbanned in japan
  • PREMATURE BURIAL call at 3 and this isn't even chainable. equips are hardly used. and wasn't the brionac main reason this was banned?
  • SUPER REJUVENATION if dragon rulers get the axe
  • IMPERIAL ORDER as most magic removal s done with monster effects anyway. todays game would not likely have much impact with multiple chainables
  • RETURN FROM THE DIFFERENT DIMENSION if they ban the rulers
  • SELF-DESTRUCT BUTTON unlimited in japan
  • SOLEMN JUDGMENT unlimited in japan

Chiissu (talk • contribs) 05:14, June 10, 2014 (UTC)

You need to realize that the meta on both sides of the ponds are drastically different, along with their desired vision of the game. Why else would the banlist have split last September? --Gadjiltron (talk • contribs) 05:28, June 10, 2014 (UTC)

ummmm, Unbanned in japan is not a good reason to be unbanned in the TCG, believe it or not we play vastly different games. more specifically.
Premature burial is banned for a lot more reasons then just Brio was a thing, or it would be back at 1 when brio bit it.
Gateway, first off, where do you want any of these things. and no, Sams can exist without that broken pile of crap
the Jars, Jackpot 7 FTK is a thing. NO ONE likes FTKs in this game.
Serpent, Everyone would run it and change their decks to be able to use it, mathmatician, foolish etc can set it up. it is a free card and while nothing right this instant can use it, they will change TO use it. Mermails especially can use this to basically halve the "cost" of megalo and make free teus. Free anything can be taken advantage of.
Dark strike fighter, Errata is only in Japan, here in the TCG it is still the most broken synchro to ever live and will not leave the list until WE get the errata.
Glow-up, no, Konami still hates synchros
TIV.....dear god no, it would never backfire, if it would you don't activate it, SS would make it free to use, there ARE decks that run single types believe it or not, and most of all DEAR GOD NO.
Magical scientist was banned for a reason, and dropping 3 xyzs is by no means the best thing it can do.
dear god i am not going to dignify the rest of that. just play traditional if you want all that back.DreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 05:40, June 10, 2014 (UTC)
By desired vision, what do you mean (as in, what it is for both)? Chromace (talk • contribs) 05:50, June 10, 2014 (UTC)
Can't clearly describe the desired vision, but based on the different list patterns, OCG seems more tolerant of game states and cards that the TCG sees as "degenerate". --Gadjiltron (talk • contribs) 07:18, June 10, 2014 (UTC)
Example of "degenerate" card: Self-Destruct Button is just plain lame. Who wants to tie in this game? All the card does is troll tournament players who are actually trying to get into the final rounds.
Also, Premature Burial is easily abused with Dewloren, Tiger King of the Ice Barrier and Mist Valley Falcon, plus a few other cards in the Mist Valley group. I might be alright with Goyo coming back, but his high ATK makes him one of the strongest Level 6 monsters in the game, but who knows what Konami might do regarding him. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 13:34, June 10, 2014 (UTC)

FORBIDDEN

  • Pot of Avarice - they should have hit this earlier. Shaddolls and some Satellarknight users use this, and it's another big turn of events.

LIMITED'"'

  • Dark Armed Dragon - It's so wrong that they made this limited to 2. Just return it to where it really should be.
  • Dragon Shrine - unlike in TCG, OCG's Dragon Ruler Decks have Dragon Ravine. But I don't think they'll hit it, because Dragunity Decks here are not catching up.
  • Soul Charge - Dragon Rulers, Satellarknights, Shaddolls, almost all decks use it. Too good to be true.for.a card.

SEMI-LIMITED

REMOVED IN THE LIST

Jampong (talk • contribs) 03:26, June 11, 2014 (UTC)


Tupac1971ful's Banlist Predictions & Explanations

BAN

All Dragon Rulers (they should eliminate Rulers)

Wind-Up Hunter (stop the loop and bring zenmighty to make WU playable again

LIMIT

Soul Charge (it needs to be hit,certain decks abuse this card so much but that's all no need to ban it)

Geargiargear (slow down geargias)

Bujin Crane (while i don't think this will happen,what else could they hit of Bujins?)

Wind-Up Zenmighty (make WU playbale again)

Goyo Guardian (Which meta-topping deck can even use this? Besides No.11 is by far more powerful and many top decks have easy access on him)

SEMI

Artifact Sanctum (slow down HAT)

Madolche Hootcake (Not likely to happen,madolches aren't as powerful as people think but if they were to hit them,hit hootcake)

Ice & Fire Hans (Hands Changed the meta dramatically,semi them is good since the hand engine will still be viable and not so powerful)

Fire Formation - Tenki (Slow down Bujins,but on the other hand this will slow down decks like fire fists and koa'ki meiru that don't need to)

Skill Drain (Semi this is good,certain decks just make you not to play)

Dragon Ravine (Rulers Banned,why not?)

Allure of Darkness (Balanced card and give a push to Dark decks)

Blackwing Gale (Did BW do anything the past formats? They're support was crap to begn with)

Dark Armed Dragon (Like the OCG this card can come back!)

Gorz (This deck doesnt see anyplay at all,only certain not-topping decks like frogs/chaos dragons may use this at 2)

Gold Sarcophagus (Rulers banned - this could also go back at 3)

Grand Mole (Why not? this card isn't even sided nowadayz)


UNLIMIT

Baby Rulers (Obvious)

Sacred Sword of Seven Stars (Rulers banned)

Hieratic Seal of Convocation (Rulers banned)

Reborn Tengu (With strong engines like hands and synchro decks being out of the meta,why not return this at 3? - also tenki being at 2 makes this hipothesis more viable)

Magician of Faith (It didn't see the slightest play at 1,will it at 3?)

Gladiator Beast Bestiari (Make GB competitive again,even at 3 Bestiari i don't think GB's will change the Meta) Tupac1971ful (talk • contribs) 10:05, June 11, 2014 (UTC)

The problem with hitting Bestiari is related more to Gladiator Beast Gyzarus spam, it's not really the deck in general. As for Hands, they're cool, but they didn't really change the meta, just made certain meta decks have answers to common problems. As for H.A.T., Traptrix Artifacts were already a deck in the OCG, but the Hands gave the deck even more Control ability. Seal of Convocation is more for Hieratic Decks in general, they're a very spammy deck and even if Rulers left, I'd still like to see Seal at 2. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 16:37, June 11, 2014 (UTC)

Gyzarous spam is indeed strong,but is that still enough to transformate GB's into an unstappable deck? Sure gyzarous spam will pop most of your cards (if it gets through in a heavy backrow and hand trap format) but that doesn't make the deck so unfair imo. There are so many decks outhere that get pluses everyturn for free. Also hands are floaters like none in the yugioh history. They can be teched in any deck and after poping a card they replace themselves with a new hand. (floater cards tend to do either of those things,not both). And they do affect heavily the meta,many decks top cause of the hand engine.Οn a first aspect that's good to help non-meta decks but on the other hand they are unfair cards that ruin the gameplay and originality --Tupac1971ful (talk • contribs) 18:40, June 11, 2014 (UTC)

I get that, but they're inherent flaw is that they need to destroy a card to summon the next floater. If Ice Hand can't destroy a Spell/Trap, it won't summon Fire Hand, and if Fire Hand can't destroy a monster, you can't summon Ice Hand. The Hands are a powerful suite of cards, but they're predictable and the only real option for the Hands is a Semi-Limit, which probably won't do that much. Most players run either 2 copies of each or the full 3, Semi-Limiting the engine will slightly hurt consistency for those who run 3, but it doesn't do anything to weaken the actual power of the Hand suite; especially with Pot of Duality Pot of Dichotomy around to put the used copies back. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 19:01, June 11, 2014 (UTC)

Pot of Dichotomy you mean? And while i haven't seen gladbeasts in a while, i no like the idea of 3 cards disappearing form 1 monster being summoned. that said, they DID just make a few new ones so i wouldn't put it past Konami to boost them somehowDreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 19:18, June 11, 2014 (UTC)

Just a bit of Data regarding the Hands:
Note: Data comes from the available decklists found at TCGPlayer.com, and I should have looked at more of the tournament deck list archives, but I went with the first 4-5 tournaments.
National Championship Belgium
  • Ruler - 3 Fire/Ice in Side
  • Evilswarm - 2 Fire/Ice in Side
National Championship Poland
  • 2nd Place - 2 Fire/Ice in Mermails
  • 5th-8th Place - 2 Fire/Ice in Geargia
National Championship Portugal
  • 5th-8th Place - 2 Fire/Ice in HAT
  • 9th-16th Place - 3 Fire/Ice in HAT
  • 9th-16th Place - 2 Fire/Ice in Side Deck of Mythic Rulers
National Championship Peru
  • 1st Place - 3 Fire/Ice in HAT
  • 5th-8th Place - 3 Fire/Ice in HAT
  • 5th-8th Place - 2 Fire/Ice in Madolche
Atlantic City Regionals
  • 5th-8th Place - 2 Fire/Ice in Gravekeepers
Lots of people only ran two hands (Main or Side) and still had success, so semi-limiting the engine might do absolutely nothing. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 19:15, June 11, 2014 (UTC)

The thing about the hands that balances them is that they 1) have to hit the grave to trigger, so you can stop them with stuff like Debunk or Abyss-Dweller, and 2) have to summon themselves from the deck to work, thus drawing into all of them sucks, kinda like Tengu, but he's slightly more versatile in synchro decks and with Divine Wind of Mist Valley. They're just the most generic way of decent monster and S/T removal right now because the other stuff like Heavy is gone. To be honest the hands will probably be tolerable through power creep. By the time we get brokedolls later this year, they'd be fine. I'd rather deal with the hands than midrash any day. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 00:55, June 12, 2014 (UTC)

So what is concluded is this :

1) Hands are annoying as they top in any deck on competitive tables

2) Semi-limiting them won't do the thing as most people run them at 2

3) Still some think that they are not that of a problem and they shoudn't be hit at all.

Imo, Hands are splashable cards that remove your opponent's monster/backrow line pretty easily without any general cost and they still replace themselves making them pluses. Supposed at this banlist the dominant decks (geargia,bujin etc.) are hit.I wouldn't like the next format to be an utterly "Hand" format and if they won't get hit that's what i anticipate. Hands don't have to bring another hand from the deck to destroy the card on the field, so i would place them on the limited list as they won't bring mass pluses and still can do their work (not so perfectly though). --Tupac1971ful (talk • contribs) 10:44, June 12, 2014 (UTC)

Are you saying you'd rather have the Hands Limited at one each? Or just placed somewhere on the F&L list? --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 13:24, June 12, 2014 (UTC)

Personally yes i'd rather them being both limited,but what is more likely to happen is that hands will be untouched or just semi to slow a bit decks abusing them at 3. --Tupac1971ful (talk • contribs) 20:23, June 12, 2014 (UTC)

They'll never really be used at one each, they could be used while both of them are at one, but it's just more effective to use one-for-one removal cards at that point. There isn't a consistent method to search for the Hands except for Mother Grizzly into Ice Hand. It's very likely that Konami won't touch the Hands, even if they did, it wouldn't have any real effect, as many decks can run 2 Fire: 2 Ice and still be just as effective if not more effective as a deck running 3:3. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 20:42, June 12, 2014 (UTC)

Probably WAY late to mention this, but as much as I'd love to see Goyo come back (1st Synchro Monster!) it isn't gonna happen. Goyo is more powerful and far more easily splashable than Big Eye, and can in theory be used an unlimited number of times. Also, you can revive it without issues. Sanokal K-T (talk • contribs) 22:47, June 13, 2014 (UTC)

That's true and his 2800 ATK for a Level 6 with a good effect is kinda crazy. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 02:41, June 14, 2014 (UTC)

Hextros500's thought

Banilist Prediction

Banned

The Senior Dragon Rulers: Even at one, they're still overpowered for the players to overcome.

Limited

Beelze: Although it does have some weaknesses, Beelze its like still too powerful to deal with as it can't be destroyed by battle or card effects. Thus making the players Rage Quit as soon as it was summoned to the field. Three of them will probably be too much.

Geargiagear: It has become very too fast for the challengers. If Geargia have slow down a bit, it will give the other players a chance to win or not.

Soul Charge: Its kind of like a game changer as the player summon many monsters from the graveyard

Bujingi Crane: This kind of like Honest effect during the damage step but I think having three is kind of a bit too much.

Judgement Dragon: This card happened to be a gamer ender as soon as the cards were destroyed with the effects and two more of them were summoned to the field and automatically ends the game.

Evilswarm Ophion: Well, Ophion is kind of overwhelming to deal with.

Semi-Limited:

Dragon Ravine: If it has at least two of them in the deck, it will give the players a chance to make a comeback with the dragons.

Unlimited

Advanced Art Ritual: The ritual deck haven't been played lately.

Beelze won't be Limited. He isn't that powerful if you consider how widely used Number 101 is. Also, I kinda feel like Beelze is just an upgraded Stardust Spark Dragon. Also, it doesn't matter if there are 3 copies of Beelze, the only deck that can really summon 2-3 is Mali Zombies. Judgement Dragon is more likely to go to two, plus the OTK you mentioned only happens with 3 JD. Also, Evilswarm Exciton Knight is much worse than JD, and JD isn't really searchable (Minerva, Lightsworn Maiden takes too long to search him, although Eclipse Wyvern is quite effective) I wouldn't mind Ophion going to one, but I think Xyz Encore really kills Evilswarms during games 2 & 3. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 21:39, June 12, 2014 (UTC)
Not to mention Castel will take it out easily too. as awesome as it is, if beelze is enough to make a ragequit then someone simply fails at building decks if they have no way over it.
How is Hootcake not on that list?DreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 21:59, June 12, 2014 (UTC)
Right, Castel the Avian Skyblaster is going to come out soon. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 01:13, June 13, 2014 (UTC)

>senior Rulers banned

>baby rulers still banned

Wat. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 03:33, June 13, 2014 (UTC)

I saw that too, but felt like it was obvious enough to not warrant a comment. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 04:09, June 13, 2014

At least keep 2 of the big dragons. I mean, why ban all of them like they are some sort of group that stays together or leaves together. I'd say get rid of blaster and tempest. I think those 2 are the most used and they can search for more useful things than what people use tidal and redox for. now of course i realize that mythic dragons are searched by tidal and redox but that deck really isn't that pwerful and wo't be that powerful especially without tempest and blaster. Even if konami decides to keep just one big dragon i'd be happy. Anyone agree with this?EHERO4LIFE! (talk • contribs) 11:15, June 13, 2014 (UTC)

Or just get rid of all of them to prevent any kinda of searching. Plus, getting rid of Tidal and Redox is probably the easiest thing to do to murder Mythic Rulers. If you ban Tidal and Redox, all the searching for the Mythics goes away and the deck is kinda killed at that point. But if you get rid of Blaster and Tempest, Cards of Consonance becomes harder to use. I also wouldn't be surprised if Konami did nothing to the Rulers. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 13:41, June 13, 2014 (UTC)

This forum always has the most out of wack banlist predictions. Its like you guys just see cards and base tour predictions based off their effects and don't even pay attention to the meta. BLS? Causes too many rage quits? When he first came off the banlist maybe but as of now, he's just there. Dark Armed banned? Where do you come up with this? He's trash now for this exact reason: priority is longer a thing. Plus someone already stated that having a beatstick is no longer tier 1. Thats all DAD is in the long run. Graceful charity, cyber dragons, oh man I could go on with how ridiculous some of these sound but lets just get to the point here: the banlist for people who actually play the game.

I dont think dragons will go away forever just due to the fact that konami has always tried to keep dragons relevant in all formats. Its just like their thing along with lots of fans of the game. On top of that they have versatility in other decks that aren't dragons.

bujins could get hit in taking away crane since they're getting that new card that is pretty much an honest that you can use in grave. No need for all that crap.

I don't think honest will get hit for the same reasons as dragons.

madolche I think is fine where its at. Anjelly is good but she's not broken. That being said whoever suggested that maybe hootcake get hit is probably on the right track. Hootcake is a better topdeck than anjelly on any day in late game so I think hitting hootcake would be a step in the right direction. But it might not happen seeing as shaddolls are coming out soon after the banlist and midrash stomps madolche but we'll see.

necroface is fine where its at. Who even brought this up? Seriously? This card is as rogue as it gets. Everything else should stay where it is.

Heavy could come back possibly just because artifacts are a thing and you're starting to see people play mst a lot more cautiously now so maybe heavy won't see that kind of reckless play we're used to. Then again even against artifacts a turn 1 heavy could break hearts if the artifact player has nothing to respond to. so maybe heavy can stay banned. --Acrylixx

Some of the users predictions are based more on facts and some are based more on personal bias. It happens on every banlist discussion I see to some degree. Just because Midrash stomps Madolche doesn't mean Madolche won't get hit, it's still likely that Madolche would get hit and then Dolls would be hit right after it on the next list. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 20:26, June 13, 2014 (UTC)

WASSUP

All the major changes happen after worlds. Expect nothing for July, all these predictions will probably come true in the next revision of the ban-list. Keep in mind that konami is a money hungry bitch and if they want to keep a broken card in to make some profit then they will. Of course they'll have to do something about it sooner or later as people stop playing just because the game gets too unfair (I don't blame them). Hold on to your panties guys.EHERO4LIFE! (talk • contribs) 21:07, June 13, 2014 (UTC)

At the same time, Konami can also choose to make a Special Banlist for Worlds. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 22:03, June 13, 2014 (UTC)
Also, I think people forget that Konami is a massive corporation and Yu-Gi-Oh! isn't it's only source of profit. So I'm not really sure if the profit thing is a valid argument. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 22:11, June 13, 2014 (UTC)

What do you guys consider to be the top decks of this format? TheOtherWhiteNerd2 (talk • contribs) 20:21, June 14, 2014 (UTC)

For me, it's HAT, Bujin, Geargia, and Madolche. There might be one or two I'm forgetting. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 21:38, June 14, 2014 (UTC)

I'd agree with HAT Bujin and Geargia. Do you think Madolche came in to this format too late? And what about Infernities and Mermails? TheOtherWhiteNerd2 (talk • contribs) 03:02, June 15, 2014 (UTC)

Madolche may have come in late, but there's still a chance for a hit. I don't think Infernity deserves a hit, but a hit on Mermails may be possible. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 03:07, June 15, 2014 (UTC)


Which of theese cards deserves a change to their banlist status?

(I don't state that theese cards should come out of the banlist,just forming an argument on what you guys think)

Card Destruction(limit) - Abusable only to DW's to gain advantage and i remember not many decks running this (except DW's) even back then when this was limited

Cyber stein(limit) High cost,can be stopped easily and if stopped correctly (veiler,fiendish chain,breakthourgh) it highly increases changes on locking on the duel,plus it gets a dead draw later on the game

Dark magician of Chaos(limit) Many people the past balists wanted this card to came out stating that there are more powerful cards around and this won't afftect the meta.

Elemental hero Stratos(limit) Most people hated yugioh when this happended. But with shadow mist and the new heroes arriving i doubt this will come ever again.

Sinister Serpent(limit) Will mermails abuse this card on their favour?

Goyo Guardian(limi) This used to be really powerful especially the Blackwing format,but synchros are nowhere especially decks that can make lvl 6 sync plays. Big eye is around being more powerful and easily summoned by many meta decks. So why not?

WU Zenmighty Ban WU Hunter and bring this one to make WU playable again!

Allure of Darkness/Dark Armed Dragon (semi) Dark Decks are nowehre and this could slightly push them to be more competitive.

Blackwing - Gale(semi) Blackwings? Have this deck even seen some competitive play? Not to mention their DRLG crap support

GB Bestiari Gyzarous spam is surely powerful but is it what can push GB's to competitive tables? i doubt it

Inzekotr Hornet(semi) Although this doesnt need to be done since inzektors are doing fine this could give them some more consistency.

Advanced ritual art(unl) Why not?

Reborn Tengu(unl) Hands are surely better than this floater plus synchro decks are mostly gone so why not?

'Chaos Sorcerer(unl)' Chaos dragons? Nahhh...

Reasoning(unl) Why is this still on the banlist?

--Tupac1971ful (talk • contribs) 16:10, June 15, 2014 (UTC)

Honestly, I've wanted DMOC to come back, but a part of me wonders if his ease of set-up and summon make him a risk to future good spell cards that could be reused. While Faith does the same thing, there are differences between a weak-flip effect monster with no real synergy in a deck and a 2800 ATK monster than can be revived with Call of the Haunted and Escape from the Dark Dimension and set up with a Foolish Burial or Lavalval Chain.
Card Destruction just sets up Dark World, Dragon Rulers, and Shadolls. Let's not.
Blackwings have seen some Regional Success in this format before Artifacts dropped. Now, would I be okay if they dropped him, sure, but he's the best tuner of the deck and his ATK reducing effect is relevant if you use it then go into a bigger Synchro monster.
I'd just not have Stratos back. I used to be a HERO player and I can tell you that he's one of the most versatile monsters in the deck when abused with Call of the Haunted. He just doesn't have a restriction. If he was limited only to a Normal Summon, I'd be fine with him. Mist if much more fair and a better replacement for him.
Goyo, huh? The truth is that he's still very easy to make in Zombies, Blackwings, Psychics, & Plants. I think he's just a little too good for a Level 6 Synchro monster. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 16:38, June 15, 2014 (UTC)

Let's go over them bit by bit shall we?

  • Card Destruction - No. Card is not only a win-button for DW if they open good enough, but it also enables special deck-out FTK's and sets up the grave too much for powerful plays in other decks.
  • Cyber-Stein - No. Card is stupid as hell and will only be used for OTK's or Lockdowns. And counters aren't a proper argument with Stein, because if he's not able to be negated, you might as well scoop.
  • DMoC - Sure. As long as all of the power spells stay banned or limited, he can come back with no serious issues. No one would bother making room for him anyways, since he'll be worthless outside of recycling a spell that should probably be banned in the first place.
  • Stratos - No, with the new HERO support and fusion support, this won't ever be coming back.
  • Sinister Serpent - Yes. Mermails won't run it when they would rather pitch other things that actually get some cool effect immediately when you pitch them.
  • Goyo - No. Highest attack of any lv 6 synchro, is generic, and steals any monster he destroys in battle (which he'll be doing a lot of with that 2800 body). And where the hell did you get the argument that most meta decks can drop big eye easier? The only one that can do it effectively anymore is Rulers, and they need to be banned on their own merit.
  • WU Zenmaity - Can come back to 1 even if Hunter isn't banned. You can't loop it unless it's at more than 1, and Avarice won't be coming back anytime soon, if ever.
  • Allure of Darkness - Ban the godawful design that is Necroface first. Then yes.
  • Dad - Sure, he's not as powerful as he once was.
  • BW Gale - Could even come to 3. We're not in 2008/2009 anymore, the deck isn't even tier 2, and a 2nd/3rd Gale won't change that.
  • GB Bestiari - ^^
  • Inzektor Hornet - Inzektors still top from time to time, they don't need a boost.
  • Advanced Ritual Art - Yes, ritual decks don't do much anymore, and a 3rd Ara won't suddenly make them meta.
  • Tengu - Sure. Konami over-reacted to plant synchro. He's a decent floater, but nothing worthy of staying on the banlist.
  • Chaos Sorcerer - Sure. Won't change much in chaos decks anyways.
  • Reasoning - Eh...if DMoC, comes back, better to keep it at 2. Otherwise, to 3 because no one runs it.

Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 00:26, June 16, 2014 (UTC)

Seems like it was too stupid of me to mention Card Destruction,forgot about shadolls! Goyo surely is a powerful lvl6 sync but the reason i mention it was because all those decks that can bring him easily aren't doing anything relevant at the meta. Well,indeed today's decks can't easily make Big Eye,my mind is 1-2 formats ago (mermails,Drulers,spellbooks) when we had big eye fights one stealing the other each turn so that's why i want goyo back,but it's more likely not to happen. --Tupac1971ful (talk • contribs) 10:24, June 16, 2014 (UTC)

Harpies can make big Eye with "Harpie Channeler", but there are plenty of ways to stop the card so it's not that broken (and you have to discard a Harpie), and even if you summon Big Eye, it still can be easily destroyed or removed off the field. Number 74 is much stronger to me most the time, but from what I see, people can easily get rid of it to even with that protection effect. Shardsilver (talk • contribs) 14:10, June 16, 2014 (UTC)

Does anyone know when the banlist will exactly be confirmed? If not,they will announce it pre or post Lightsworn's structure deck? --Tupac1971ful (talk • contribs) 15:30, June 16, 2014 (UTC)

Seeing as the banlist is usually updated about 2 weeks before the list actually takes effect, I'm going to guess that the list will be posted by Konami sometime during the weekend of June 28-29, about 1-2 days after the Structure Deck. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 15:42, June 16, 2014 (UTC)

"but the reason i mention it was because all those decks that can bring him easily aren't doing anything relevant at the meta" Don't forget if something like Goyo comes out and things can abuse it right, they can BECOME relevant. Just because most winning decks avoid synchros isn't a good reason to bring back all of the broken ones. not saying this will be relevant if it comes off, just speaking generally that "nothing relevant can do it" isn't the best of arguementsDreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 17:34, June 16, 2014 (UTC)

Confirmed OCG List, Among Other Things

The Organization has the following report/article. List + Other Stuff. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 13:28, June 17, 2014 (UTC)

Seeing as Konami updated their list on March 19 when March had 31 days, they should update their F&L list for June in about 1-2 days, right? Although maybe not. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 18:00, June 17, 2014 (UTC)
If i recall correctly we didn't have to wait very long to get our list after theirs, so that sounds about rightDreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 00:17, June 18, 2014 (UTC)

The OCG's list sucks...a lot...my comments on the changes they made?

Limited:

  • Artifact Moralltach - Bad hit was bad. It avoids the real problem with the deck, and the reason why the engine is degenerate: Sanctum. Sanctum should've been limited instead of this. Moralltach is so balanced it hurts.
  • Armageddon Knight - The fuck? They limited him and not Dark Grepher, who can special summon himself by discarding a Malicious and pitch twice? Jesus, Konami is just looking for some random scapegoat to dodge the real problem with Shadolls.
  • Dragon Ravine - Damn it, fucking ban the dragon rulers already and stop hitting innocent cards like this that are worthless without the Rulers.
  • Dragon Shrine - ^
  • Needlebug Nest - ^^

Semi-Limited:

  • Elemental HERO Bubbleman - Never should've been touched, Stratos is the real problem.
  • Chronomaly Nebra Disk - Eh, I suppose it's ok, Chronofacts were topping quite a bit pre-TDA.
  • Wind-Up Shark - I don't care about Wind-Ups anymore tbh.
  • TG Striker - Boosting old decks, sure thing.
  • Mezuki - Remind me, when was the last time zombies did anything?
  • Legendary Six Samurai - Shi En - Have you ever faced two of these on the first turn? This is ridiculous.
  • Evilswarm Ophion - Since they're getting encore soon enough, this is fine.
  • Abyss-sphere - Mermails haven't done too much, this is ok.

Unlimited:

  • Chaos Sorcerer - Don't care, card sucks nowadays.
  • Plaguespreader Zombie - Not a problem anymore.
  • Cyber-stein - Because bringing back other broken cards like Stein that are only used for OTK's/lockdowns somehow balances the currently broken cards in the game...seriously, this card is stupid as hell and should've stayed banned.
  • Rescue Rabbit - Meh, Dino Rabbits won't magically make a comeback anytime soon.
  • Fire Formation - Tenki - Sure, Fire Fists don't do much anymore anyways.
  • Royal Tribute - Jesus Christ, what the hell has gotten into the OCG? They already have a shitload of broken cards running around in their format, and now GK's have 3 of their mega-confiscations? Terrible move, should've gone to 1 or 0 if anything, no one deserves to lose every monster in their hand before they even get a turn.
  • Black Whirlwind - Blackwings suck and I don't care if they get this at 3.
  • Sacred Sword of the Seven Stars - Never should've been hit.

/end rant. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 21:54, June 24, 2014 (UTC)

TOWN's Predictions

July 2014 Banlist Predictions


Tier 1 Decks

•Bujins •Geargia •HAT •Madolche •Mermails


Support in Future Sets

•Artifacts •Bujins •Fire Fists •Shadolls •Stellarknights •Yang Zing


Banned

•I have no idea if anything will be banned, but Dark Hole won't be. Konami is releasing an Ultra Rare Dark Hole in the upcoming Space-Time Showdown starter deck and pack.


Limited

•Eclipse Wyvern - I don't think Konami wants to hit the Dragon Rulers, but are not stupid enough to let any Dragon Ruler decks dominate the meta. On that note, ever heard of Lightsworn Rulers? This deck is the new Dragon Ruler deck making rounds around the block and this card is the problem. Assuming they ban the DRulers, Lightsworn Chaos would do about the same thing (search out JD in the exact same way), but with Chaos cards such as Lightpulsar Dragon, Chaos Sorc, BLS, etc.

•Geargiarmor and/or Geargiagear - Geargia hits. Just about everyone can agree that these are the biggest hits for Geargia, but will still allow the deck to function.

•Madolche Hootcake - Madolche hit.

•Mermail Abyssteus and/or Abyss-Sphere - From what I can tell, hitting Gunde was the wrong card. Instead, these were the hits that have made the Mermails a deck of the OCG's past. We know these hits work, and otherwise Mermails will continue to be a Tier 1 deck.

•Sinister Serpent - A lot of people have for a LONG time said that this card never deserved to be hit, much less banned. Remembering that Konami has slowly been bringing back Staples of GOAT Control, I predict that this card may be the next GOAT Control staple to be "unshackled", if any are.

•Traptrix Myrmeleo - It searches Bottomless, Traptrix Nightmare, and such other great cards. It has semi-decent stats and helps grant access to Rank 4 decks. Something whispers to me, "This card will be hit."

•Soul Charge - Of course this card is here. We all knew this card was getting hit.

•Kaiser Coliseum - This card is exploited by Bujins and their "protect the castle" style of play. Kaiser is definitely a card that says the opponent can't play Yu-Gi-Oh!, , but you can. Kaiser decks are not necessarily the best Bujin decks, but they are some of the most consistently topping versions. This deck is likely the most problematic to the player base, as the opponent cannot play.


Semi-limited

•Fire and/or Ice Hand - HAT decks are a bit of a problem. Konami is releasing more Artifacts/Artifact support in the future, so I don't see those cards being hit. However, by hitting these and Myrmeleo, you've greatly weakened the deck, and the engines themselves.

•Gorz, the Emissary of Darkness - It's time, guys... Gorz has done nothing for a few formats now. It's time to bring this card back.

•Allure of Darkness - Boost for Shaddolls. I know a lot of people wanted Dark Armed Dragon to come back, but I don't think Konami is ready to even bring back the possibility of Tele-DAD.

•Reinforcement of the Army - Warrior decks have done nothing for formats now and moreso helps Stellarknights.


Newly Unlimited

•Dark Strike Fighter - Only if this card's errata'd version is released. The TCG is getting a 5D's Mega Tin in the upcoming months, so even if not brought back on the next list, I think Konami will bring it back next format, perhaps in the middle.

•Advanced Ritual Art - Ritual decks have done nothing major in the meta for a while now.

•Reasoning - Slight boost to Sylvans, but moreso a card that's done nothing for a while now.


Other than these, I can see Fire Fists getting a boost and maybe Trishula coming back to 1 as a boost for Yang Zing. However, I'm not as convinced those two things will happen as I am the above list.

TheOtherWhiteNerd2 (talk • contribs) 02:31, June 19, 2014 (UTC)

Don't think shaddolls need a boost of anysort, especially as they aren't even here yet and i state my opinion on the serpent several times. otherwise that looks good to meDreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 00:21, June 18, 2014 (UTC)

FatMan2539's List

here's my wants/predictions for this list

Forbidden

the big rulers: 'nuff said (even though i play 1 redox to get eclipse wyvern banished faster)

BLS - envoy: I play it, but it's still too good

Limited

Artifact Moralltach: basically their key card

stratos: it's not that bad

glow up bulb: i dont see how "once per duel" should be banned in the first place

DMoC: look at MoF and what it hasnt been doing

dragons ravine: if the big rulers go to 0, this should be at at least 1

skill drain: even though it's not too meta, this is still an annoying card to say the least

soul charge: make decks that rely mostly on this so much less consistent

yamato/turtle/crane: any one of these (pref. turtle or crane)

101: this thing can steal games in it's self

Semi-Limited

bottomless: we need it at 2 again, 1 is not enough and 3 is too much

sacred sword: if the big dragons go to 0, this is much less useful (i know mermails and such, but still)

formula: since most players don't go for lvl 2 synchros unless its in a quasar deck... and puralis sucks and quasar was a promo anyways, so formula isnt that bad

debris dragon: if rulers get hit

gold sarc: if the rulers go to 0, this is no where near as much of a threat... and 2 seems like a good testing point for konami

back to 3

macro and d-fissure WHAT ABOUT THE D.D ARCHETYPE... survivor, plane, Golden Homunculus and gren maju, this should be a thing (if it was never meta)

thousand eyes: this isnt that good and would do nothing at 3 (well... no more than No. 11)

tengu: no brio, so tengu aint that bad

mirror force: no major meta players play this, so i doubt konami wouldnt do this

transmIg (idk how to make an "i" be more pronounced in text so i capitalised it): as above

notes

NO, goyo can not come back... yes it has to attack to get its effect off, but its effect (when it goes off, and it will because it's 2800) is the douchey side of m-reb

I didnt say No. 11 or Dracossack because if the rulers go away, these will be much less common (imo)

Discussion

feel free to discuss my picks ~F.~ 09:32, June 20, 2014 (UTC)

I doubt Konami will ban the big Dragon Rulers. They've had multiple formats and refuse to, so yeah... Bujins do NOT need a hit outside of Kaiser to 0 or 1 and maybe Tenki to 2. Hit these and the deck is very manageable. D.D. Archetype is fun, but Macro and Fissure are not. Konami has yet to bring a card from 0 to 3, so I doubt that even if they do bring back TERestrict (which is unlikely to happen seeing as how GOAT Control is their most hated deck of all time), it'll at first be to one. TheOtherWhiteNerd2 (talk • contribs) 11:24, June 20, 2014 (UTC)

i guess you're right about 0 - 3 not happening, but i have a question... what _was_ goat control, i mean ive heard of its existence , but never done any more looking in to it ~F.~ 15:06, June 20, 2014 (UTC)
it was an old deck, basic idea was to use Metamorphosis to drop Thousand eyes restrict, abuse his effect to eat monsters, book of moon him to drop the absorbed monster and to allow your other monsters to attacj, flip him back up to eat another monster and use his effect to not allow them to fight back. the deck was banhammered into oblivion with every component that made it work banned or limited. as teh name implies Scapegoat and creature swap were used alot in it too. you kill the opponent with thier own monsters essentiallyDreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 20:18, June 20, 2014 (UTC)
While the deck was murdered into oblivion, it still exists in a newer form using The Atmosphere, also while Goat Control was a very interesting deck, I don't think it was actually that bad. While Metamorphosis should remained banned due to abuse, I think that TER could come back with very few issues, yes it still protects itself from dying in battle, but pretty much everybody has access to generic monster removal, either in the form of Number 50: Blackship of Corn, Number 101: S H Ark Knight, Castel the Avian Skyblaster, Maestroke the Symphony Djinn, as well as a plethora of monster removal spell/traps. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 20:26, June 20, 2014 (UTC)
I'm not sure but I think the only reason Goat Control was "banhammered" was because a lot of the cards that went along with it were really good anyway :P I mean let's be real: Metamorphosis was a ridiculous card, TER used to be crazy too, and scapegoat needs no explanation. The Deck itself probably wasn't too bad, I just think it got the short end of the stick with its prime components being really good to begin with. Also, remember the meta was way different a long time ago, so it might have received the ban hammer because it was highly disruptive and infuriating back then. Idk lol Aeron Solo wuz here (If you wanna talk) 20:48, June 20, 2014 (UTC)

Other ways to play a NEO GOAT deck: Destiny HERO Plasma, and Relinquished. The deck was great because it also ran Tsukiyomi to destroy the monsters that you stole by game mechanics. Also, it had a TON of Power Magic cards, like Delinquint Duo, Heavy, Reborn, Pot of Greed, Graceful Charity, etc. Yeah, a number of the cards could come back, but this was a deck that Konami hated more than ANY other deck to ever become meta in the game of Yu-Gi-Oh! TheOtherWhiteNerd2 (talk • contribs) 21:21, June 20, 2014 (UTC)

But it was only hated because it spat in the face of traditional way the game was played. It's no longer 2005, most of the broken cards the deck ran back then are never coming back. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 23:31, June 20, 2014 (UTC)
It was only really hated by Konami. It was easily THE most played deck of the format, likely rivaling Dragon Rulers of two formats ago in the percentage of how much it was played. Perhaps even moreso than DRulers were. They hated it more because nobody wanted to buy what they were promoting.
TheOtherWhiteNerd2 (talk • contribs) 23:53, June 20, 2014 (UTC)
Not surprising, Konami also uses the logic of keeping things non-stagnant in a format as justification for some card hits, which it kinda used on a article post on their site a long while back. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 01:39, June 21, 2014 (UTC)

I'm surprised i didn't get a wall of text stating how broken glow up bulb could be at one because of how broken it was in its time (even though I fail to see it and i wasn't playing during its time so idk what the combos were) ~F.~ 06:58, June 25, 2014 (UTC)

It's not really that Glow-Up is somehow broken, it's just that it's too easy to set up with Lonefire, One for One, and a few other cards Plants and Sylvans tend to run. --Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 13:42, June 25, 2014 (UTC)

My Predictions

Banned

Kaiser Colosseum - This card basically gives you control of the game.

Instant Fusion - I have the feeling Konami of TCG will do this, if not, then later on.

Limited

Artifact Moralltach - Basically will kill the artifact engine that is put in other decks, and can be abused with Call of the Haunted or something that can special summon it on your opponent's turn. Better than hitting Artifact Sanctum, cause that will just kill Artifacts in general.

Fire Hand/Ice Hand - After YCS Philly, these 2 were basically being splashed in almost EVERY deck, and they are just annoying.

Mermail Abyssteus - Mermails are still too good and hitting 'Mermail Abyssgunde' didnt do anything.

Eclipse Wyvern - The new Lightsworn structure deck is coming out and this card is basically 'get your 'Judgment Dragon' before it gets milled'. Its easy to banish it through the Dragon Rulers, 'Lightray Diabolos', 'Black Luster Soldier - Envoy of the Beginning', etc.

Sinister Serpent - Just get this card off the banned status, this card won't do any impact in the format and probably never will!

Dark Magician of Chaos - Requires 2 tributes to summon this, Magician of Faith didn't do anything, and most of the loops with him cannot be done. Just like Magician of Faith, there is no good spell cards you can retrieve outside of Dark Hole, Book of Moon, Soul Charge (If it gets Limited or Banned), and probably Foolish Burial. Its not as if he is gonna put an impact in the format.

Soul Charge - Either limit or even Ban it. Its not as OP as I though, but just hit it.

Dragon Shrine - Dragon Rulers are still being seen alot even though they were hit format after format.

Geargiagear - This card makes geargias just too good. Basically a plus 1 and an instant rank 4 for geargias, especially for Xyz summoning Gear Gigant X.

Black Horn of Heaven - Free negation, Stops Inherit Special Summons and Extra deck Summons (Except Fusion Monsters that doesnt summon itself through Contact Fusion). Basically hit this to reduce the mass trap count we have during the meta.

Traptrix Trap Hole Nightmare - Can be searched through Traptrix Myrmeleo, and negates effects free, although it is limited to monsters that are special summoned that turn. Basically like 'Black Horn of Heaven'.

Semi-Limited

Blackwing - Gale the Whirlwind - Blackwings arent doing anything.

Dark Armed Dragon - Not as great as it used to be.

Kagetokage - Reduces rank 4 spam in most decks and can be searched by 'King of the Feral Imps', which is a generic rank 4 monster.

Magician of Faith - It did nothing throughout the 2 formats that it was limited after it lefted the Banned status.

Neo-Spacian Grand Mole - Its not really good anymore as it was. No one really even uses it anyways.

Thunder King Rai-Oh - It didnt do anything or was seen in decks and probably wont do anything when Shaddolls come out.

Formula Synchron - Most of the good Level 1 tuners are banned. Its not really gonna no any real impact anymore. No one wouldn't probably run more than 1.

Divine Wind of Mist Valley - The FTK is already dead with 'Genex Ally Birdman' Limited and 'Elemental HERO Stratos' Banned. Harpies aren't doing anything. In Fact, WIND isn't doing anything in general throughout the past formats.

Monster Gate - No one uses this card.

One for One - Its basically a minus 1 to bring a level 1 monster from your hand or deck. I doubt this card will cause an impact at 2.

Sacred Sword of Seven Stars - This card was abused when the big Dragon Rulers were at 3 each. This card didn't even need to get hit, and if Mermail Abyssteus gets hit, this card might as well get semi'd or even unlimited, cause this card is already balanced and mediocre.

Skill Drain - This card is just so annoying in general. I don't get why it even lefted the list in the first place.

The Transmigration Prophecy - Just because it can loop itself doesn't mean it is automatically busted. Its basicaly now more of an anti-meta card that people are just gonna throw in their side deck. I highly doubt its gonna make an impact.

Wall of Revealing Light - 'Mystical Space Typhoon' and 'Wiretap' can kill this card. Stall cards aren't good in general, and 'Self-Destruct Button' and 'Last Turn' are banned so...

Unlimited

Chaos Sorcerer - Chaos decks doesn't do anything. I don't think people are even gonna run more than 2 anyways cause it can get too cloggy.

Gladiator Beast Bestiari - Gladiator Beast, even with their new support, aren't even doing anything. And no one will really run more than 2.

Reborn Tengu - This card is not as good as it used to be, also the Hands are way better than this card.

Summoner Monk - You need to discard 1 spell card and if it gets hit by Effect Veiler, Fiendish Chain, or 'Breakthrough Skill', you basically minus yourself. No one really uses him anymore.

Tragoedia - No one cares about this card.

Thousand-Eyes Restrict - Only if Instant Fusion gets Limited or even Banned.

Advanced Ritual Art - Ritual Decks don't do anything.

Reasoning - No one cares about this card.

These are my thoughts on what should get hit.Guardian Skunk (talk • contribs) 05:23, June 22, 2014 (UTC)

Well for things that loop themselves like Transmigration prophecy, its nto so much that it is automatically busted in that Konami just has a history of killing things that can do that regardless of whether or not it is viable.DreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 20:47, June 22, 2014 (UTC)
I don't see a reason to hit Instant Fusion. It's not really a broken card that leads to game-ending plays. While it can Summon Midrash and set-up a Shaddoll Fusion the next turn, that by itself isn't a good enough reason for it to be Banned. --Dark Ace SP (Talk) 18:14, June 23, 2014 (UTC)
Maybe limited once Noden is a thingDreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 00:20, June 25, 2014 (UTC)
I doubt Instant Fusion will be hit. Instant Fusion is balanced and forces you to dedicate extra deck space to use it, and extra space is very tight as it is nowadays. @DreadKaiser, no one would use Instant Fusion for Noden. Although, I do think Super Poly might become very strong with him. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 02:40, June 25, 2014 (UTC)
No, people do use Instant to Summon Noden. There's quite a bit of appeal in using Instant Fusion to make a quick Rank 4 that can steal back the game. --Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 03:30, June 25, 2014 (UTC)
Actually i have seen instant fusion Nodens into ARKS and Castels quite a lot on YGOpro, so its essentially a 1 card and 1000LP for a rank 4 problem solver. Have also seen Super fusions into Noden just as much.......so I can second that idea of it being really good with him. Super'd my Quasar and Librarian into ARK and ate my Junk destroyer with it, then killed me......Twice.....yeah its good with Super fusionDreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 03:33, June 25, 2014 (UTC)
On the flip side, it could also be a problem with Noden himself, although I find it somewhat less likely they'll do that. I find it more painful when super poly is used because then they get rid of two of my monsters, make noden into ark or castel and kill a 3rd monster. What's even more BS is that you can't negate Super Poly and it's a quick-play, Instant Fusion into Noden is decent but if I were to go so far as to hit something, I'd be more inclined to hit super poly than Instant Fusion, simply because killing 3 of my monsters hurts a lot more than killing one. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 03:57, June 25, 2014 (UTC)

Noden is not an exclusive Korean card by the way ? In that case I see it hardly be touched him or Instant Fusion in the TCG banlist...KiryuRPG (talk • contribs) 10:39, June 25, 2014 (UTC)

IF we ever get Noden over here, then maybe they'll hit those two cards. Infernities already play Instant Fusion and Noden is just a better Level 4 option. As for Super Poly, it actually becomes a decent side deck option thanks to Noden. However, those arguments are invalid as they don't yet exist. So only if we ever get Noden in the TCG will those cards ever need to be considered to be hit.

TheOtherWhiteNerd2 (talk • contribs) 11:19, June 25, 2014 (UTC)

Yeah, the discussion was about what could be hit if Noden came to the TCG. --Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 13:37, June 25, 2014 (UTC)

I know this might be too stupid to ask, but doesn't Advanced Ritual art have graveyard setup potential? --LG Talk 15:49, June 27, 2014 (UTC)

To some degree yes, but the monsters that were yarded are Normals, and very few decks have a use for Normals in the grave. Of course their are exceptions, for example Master Hyperion is able to use them as fuel for his effect and Doom Dozer is able to use Insect Normals to his summon (Demise Dozer is a real deck). However, the decks that can use the graveyard for later are few and far between and there are consistency issues if you randomly through in a Ritual and ARA. --Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 16:01, June 27, 2014 (UTC)
Hyperion? Ok, Now they should ban ARA. JK (I hate that deck as much as I hate Lightsworns, which is alot) But yeah, Best Ritual I've seen so far is Garlandolf, King of Destruction and even he isn't that good :/ --LG Talk 16:26, June 27, 2014 (UTC)
Herald of Perfection and his big brother Herald of Glorious Light are the best Rituals ever, plus Dark Factory of Mass Production makes it easy to recycle Normals Fairies for the Heralds. Herald of Glorious Light is harder to summon, but I don't mind dumping 2 Gyakutenno Megami with Advanced Ritual Art then using Agents to keep a big hand size. --Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 18:25, June 27, 2014 (UTC)
Advanced Ritual Art is a very balanced card on it's own, not only do you have to have normal monsters to use it, but you also have to have the ritual monster itself in your hand to use it. If there's a problem with anything, hit the ritual monster themselves. As for Guardian Skunk's predictions (which is what this subsection is on...
  • Instant Fusion - No. Even when Noden eventually comes out for the TCG, Super Poly is a far superior card and more likely to be hit.
  • Kaiser Colosseum - No...just no.
  • Artifact Moralltach - No, Sanctum is the right card to hit. Moralltach is actually very balanced on it's own, and Sanctum is the only reason the engine is even splashable in the first place.
  • Fire Hand and Ice Hand - No way. The Hands are balanced S/T and monster removal cards. The only reason they're used so much now is because of the lack of many other alternatives, but what's better than having 4 or 5 commonly used cards, is having 4 or 5 commonly used cards that are balanced, like the hands.
  • Wyvern - Why? Even then, JD itself would be more hitworthy than Wyvern ever would be.
  • Dragon Shrine - Stop finding scapegoats and just ban the rulers themselves already.
  • Black Horn and Trap Hole Nightmare - No, they're fine where they're at.
  • Kagetokage - Seriously? Have you paid attention to anything within the last few months? No one runs this card, because it's mediocre and many decks have better options on their own.
  • Divine Wind of Mist Valley - See this video and tell me how the FTK is dead even at 1.
  • Skill Drain - No....just stop at this point, this card is about as rogue as rogue gets. The graveyard is far more important than the field and decks revolving around this haven't done anything in ages. Leave it be.
  • Thousand-Eyes Restrict - Card sucks and could go to 3 regardless of Instant Fusion's status on the list. No one would use it when people already have access to 101 and soon-to be Castel.
  • The rest, I have no comment on or agree with.

Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 00:59, June 28, 2014 (UTC)

Watch someone revive the negation power of those God damned Dino Rabbits with that new Herald of Glorious Light --LG Talk 04:16, June 28, 2014 (UTC)

Dragon8u2 ban list predictions

Before I begin I have to make a comment to all those who play on devpro like I do. You've all seen how broken tellaknights and shaddolls are. Tellaknights bouce everything on the field except for their xyz back to the hand every single turn. Which makes xyz and syncros useless. Shaddolls consistently stop special summoning except for once per turn. Even worse yang zing have the potential to be as good as the full power dragon rulers. That being said it seems like konami needs to speed up the format. Not only would it make gameplay more exciting, it would also still be balanced because of the enormous amount of back row and no heavy storm. Which would stop most overpowered plays. So if we release key cards from the banlist that we've always been wanting to use, it would still balance out.

Banned: (stupid concept unless something actually breaks the game)

Nothing new needs banned, if anything a lot needs to come off this list and go to limited. It literally makes the new cards u spent all that money on absolutely worthless. Plus doing this would increase konami's sales since so many people are afraid of buying things cuz it might get put on this list.

Dark magician of chaos needs to stay on here tho. Mostly cuz of the new card dark renewal. Shock master needs to stay as well cuz of tellaknights Monster reborn needs to stay (sadly) because of tellaknights. Shaddolls too.

Limited:

Bujin Crane (either limited or at 2)

Substitoad (give pure frogs something they aren't even tier right now)

Mind master (psychic's suck)

Glow-up Bulb (why is this banned?)

Thousand Eyes restrict (can get stopped so easy it's not even funny and takes so much to go into)

Dark Strike Fighter (seriously why is this banned?)

Goyo Guardian (to make legit zombies a thing again, plus compared to big eye and that shit he really sucks anymore)

Brionac Dragon of the Ice barrier (ice barriers suck and this card does exact same thing as the tellaknight xyz but makes you ditch a lot of cards, this isn't broken)

Wind up carrier zenmaity (wind ups need to come back)

Elemental Hero Stratos (yes they can spam it but there are so many cards like this out there that this is NEEDED)

Spellbook of Judgement (1 wont hurt anything)

Gateway of the Six (THIS NEEDS TO COME BACK, seriously there is no reason at all for this to be banned, all you did there is murder an archtype)

Future fusion (cuz mst negation with continuous spells is a thing now cuz of tenki)

Solemn Judgement (it's half your life points come on)

burner, lightning, stream, and reactan (ya they are amazing but if u get this card and dont have a vaild target in your deck it becomes completely dead, plus there is so much anti special summoning support out right now that it's not even right, plus in case u didnt notice mind drain kills all dragon ruler plays.

Abyss-Sphere (because the combo with mermail abysslinde is broken)

Semi-Limited:

Dragon Ravine (This needs to come back! dragunitys need this card, cuz ya there are cards that can abuse this but lets face it most of those decks wont be able to do much anymore without this. plus no need to exterminate an archtype)

Blaster, Redox, Tempest, Tidal (I know this is where a lot of people will rage at me but hear me out. Gold sarc is at 1, super rejuvination at 1, sword of seven stars is at 1. They literally murdered the deck and the support at the same time. The deck isnt great without support purely just because they have little to no draw power and require ditching so many cards. If the deck came back right now, especially because of tellaknights and Shaddolls one special summon per turn effect, dragon rulers wont go above tier 2, that's where hieratic rulers will be this format as well. Also because kaiser colosseum and vanity's emptiness is a huge thing right now, and macro shuts them down without draw power)

Atlantean Dragoons (atlanteans need to be a thing again)

Gladiator Beast Bestari (gladiator beast deck needs to be at least tier 3)

Wind-up magician (wind ups need support back)

Rescue Rabbit (dino rabbits were really good and aren't even close to broken anymore)

Macro Cosmos and Dimensional Fissure (good support cards, easily destroyed, and they made D.D. a valid archtype, plus they really hurt dragon rulers and hieratic as a side deck)

Soul Drain (this is only a possably in case dragon rulers or hieratic rulers get too overpowered)

Judgement Dragon (this needs to be at 2, spamming 3 JD in one turn is just broken, either this or they need to change destruction effect to once per turn)

Lumina, Lightsworn summoner (love the card but it's an instant michael, too good)

Bujin Yamato (deck revolves around him, this will slow it down a little)

Satellaknight Altair (deck revolves around him)

Celestial Factor (broken if used on the xyz)

Stellarknight Triveil (broken as hell)

Shaddoll Fusion (broken as hell, and recyclable thru the effect of every fusion monster, this might need to go down to limited)


Thats all for the list I believe, tell me what you think below. I honestly hope this is where yugioh is headed, the format would be greatly sped up, a lot of our favorite monsters would come back with a vengance, and the game would become more fun in the long run. And above all else there are no archtypes in the game completely banned except for the stall decks. Thanks for reading and I hope konami follows my lead on this, because if you try to keep the format at current speed you would have to kill most if not all of the shaddolls and satellaknights power just to make it fair. I don't want that to happen and I don't think you do either, espcially cuz they just came out. cuz both those decks will be tier 1 no matter what. Dragon8u2 (talk • contribs) 16:23, June 29, 2014 (UTC)

Mind Master (Psychics sucks any-
Stopped reading right there, not even going to justify the rest of that with a responce. and if you really don't know why dark strike fighter is banned, you must not have been playing this game for very long. he is only the most broken monster to ever exist. that all but assures the game ends on its summon. Forum:Reasons why cards are Forbidden/Limited.

study up, then make predictions.DreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 17:17, June 29, 2014 (UTC)

Fighter can now come back because he's been errated, but Dragon8u2, you really should read why the cards are banned in the first place. Also Konami has a history of not hitting new Archetypes. --Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 17:21, June 29, 2014 (UTC)
Also, the TCG won't get Shaddolls and tellerknights until like August, so it's more likely that they'll be allowed to roam for 1 - 2 formats in the TCG. --Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 17:30, June 29, 2014 (UTC)
Not errata'd in the TCG yet, moot point since there is no doubt it will come down once it is.DreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 18:05, June 29, 2014 (UTC)
Fighter's text has already been changed on the Official Card Database, which is where Konami has decided to inform us of future errata changes, a print will come in Legendary Collection 5D's. --Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 19:06, June 29, 2014 (UTC)
Oh ok thenDreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 19:27, June 29, 2014 (UTC)

Limited:

Bujin Crane - One of the least necessary hits Bujin needs. Outside of Kaiser and maybe Tenki, the deck is actually not that great. It's a good deck, but it's one of the least powerful "Tier 1 decks" in a while. They don't need this card, much less Yamato to be hit.

Substitoad - No comment.

Mind master - Lol? Loops? OP? Card is banworthy.

Glow-up Bulb - I actually agree with this.

Thousand Eyes restrict - ^^

Dark Strike Fighter - Only if it's errata'd version is released.

Goyo Guardian - Too strong. I mean it's body is literally too strong. Sure, it's eff isn't as good as it once was, but it's too strong and too splashable.

Brionac Dragon of the Ice barrier - Meh.

Wind up carrier zenmaity - I agree.

Elemental Hero Stratos - They have Shadow Mist, so Stratos is obselete. His main use is taken care of.

Spellbook of Judgement - No. Just no. This card is too good. Not even exaggerating, I've seen duels where people go plus 7 off of this card.

Gateway of the Six - Meh.

Future fusion - No. It will be so abusable in Chaos Dragons/Chaos/DRulers. Also, counters for a card should never be a reason for a card to come back.

Solemn Judgement - It's always live, is Spell Speed 3, stops everything, and it's not 4000, just half. So it can be as small as 1 lp. I believe on average the cost was around 2000? Also, with Soul Charge, average cost will drop. That being said, I actually wouldn't mind seeing it return. I just don't think it will.

burner, lightning, stream, and reactan - Meh.

Abyss-Sphere - Yes plz!

Semi-Limited:

Dragon Ravine - Either bring this off the list, or give Dragunities a replacement. Although, with this and Future Fusion DRulers would be broken.

Blaster, Redox, Tempest, Tidal - Wait, what? Look, the deck is Tier 0 when the DRulers are at anything past 1. I'm not salty, I love DRulers. Synchro Rulers is one of my top 3 decks of all time. But I can recognize that they don't need to be past 1.

Atlantean Dragoons - Meh.

Gladiator Beast Bestari - Gladiator Deck might actually be Tier 3; they've topped a little bit this format. Although, I'd like to see the card come back.

Wind-up magician - Zenmaity is really all the need. This opens up loops.

Rescue Rabbit - Ehhh... Maybe.

Macro Cosmos and Dimensional Fissure - Won't happen. Hurts the new decks too much.

Soul Drain - ^^

Judgement Dragon - Maybe. Although, with Rulersworn, it would be better to hit Wyvern to 1. This IS a hit to Lightsworn, and Konmoney has just released the Realm of Light Structure Deck, so meh.

Lumina, Lightsworn summoner - ^^

Bujin Yamato - See Crane. Also, this is THE WORST WAY TO HIT THE DECK. The deck does not really need to be hit.

Satellaknight Altair - Not gonna happen. Archetypes aren't even out yet.

Celestial Factor - ^^

Stellarknight Triveil - ^^^

Shaddoll Fusion - ^^^^

TheOtherWhiteNerd2 (talk • contribs) 19:04, June 29, 2014 (UTC)

Ok, let's see...

Limited:

Bujin Crane - Agreed.

Substitoad - Have you ever played with this card before? No, card is stupid as hell, causes too many FTK's and loops and can drop 4 xyz's in one turn. To 0 forever.

Mind master - You seriously need to look up your facts...Like Substitoad, the card causes way too many OTK's and FTK's, most notably one with Exodia and Caam, Serenity of Gusto.

Glow-up Bulb - Free, non-cost tuner revival whenever you want, and most splashable tuner in the game. Any deck can and will run it if it comes back. Stays at 0.

Thousand Eyes restrict - Agreed. Could even come to 3, Instant Fusion into this is way outclassed.

Dark Strike Fighter- Wait until the TCG gets the OPT errata. Until then, it's a pure OTK machine.

Goyo Guardian - Jesus Christ, you need to have some simple common sense from time to time. Generic lv 6 synchro that can be splashed into anything that can run a tuner or two, has a whopping 2800 atk, and steals any monster he kills. Absolute shit design, to 0 forever.

Brionac Dragon of the Ice barrier My god where's your brain at, this thing is stupid as f**k. Can wipe the entire field by itself, has no once per turn, is generic, and the discard turns into free pluses in Mermails. Never comes back.

Wind up carrier zenmaity - Eh...it might.

Elemental Hero Stratos - No, it's not needed, it's a badly designed card that would force you to hit balanced cards like E-Call and A HERO Lives to even consider unbanning it. HERO's are getting new support anyways and they don't need this.

Spellbook of Judgement Dear god I'm not even going to bother replying to you on this one, you obviously have had no experience with how this card and spellbooks work.

Gateway of the Six - Have you ever played Six Sams before? This card is just a turn 1 free win-button for the deck, they're still viable without this.

Future fusion - You know what? Fuck it. I'm done. I'm not even gonna bother replying to how ridiculous the rest of your moves are, just play traditional if you want all of that garbage back, or read this page to get a better understanding of why those cards are banned.

Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 20:21, June 29, 2014 (UTC)

and im the only one who realizes hes trolling. Chiissu (talk • contribs) 20:31, June 29, 2014 (UTC)

I don't think he's trolling per se, he just has a different view of how he wants the game to take shape. It would be a step in the absolute worst direction for many people, since they want most of the unfair cards back or to be bumped. Hastydemon2 (talk • contribs) 23:51, June 29, 2014 (UTC)

Banned

  • Beelze - very annoying
  • exciton - its really self explanatory of why it should be banned
  • Rulers - i believe is time that is all

Limited

  • soul charge - it is balanced because you have to pay LP and also lose your battle Phase but this card can be a staple and so much can be done with this one card
  • Madolche hootcake - with the anjelly combo to get an OTK is too broken. i have no problem with angelly at 3 because is the monster that she brings out which is usually hootcake that is the problem.
  • Pot of Avarice - i can see that they banned it probably because we have pot of dichotomy but i just dont see the problem with this card
  • Black Sonic - i love this card in my blackwings but seriously its a super buffed mirror force and another thing it can be played from the hand as well too broken, with that blackwings dont have to worry about MTS popping it.
  • fire hand/ice hand - Like really this is just too much, they just keep destroying things and then just keeps summoning each other
  • Dark strike fighter - the effect has been changed so its not that crazy as back then

Semi-limited

  • Tenki- Slow Bujins and Fire Fist
  • Grand Mole - i love the neo spacians and grand mole is one of there best cards plus no one really uses him and not a threat like that.
  • Formula synchron - like why not because to me is not much of threat and i dont see quasar being played that much

Unlimited

  • Magician of faith - she is not really used so why not
  • summoner monk - you have to discard a spell card first of all and its really easy to stop
  • Card Trooper - Why not? people use kuribandit more so it should just go to 3

For people who are saying ROTA to 2 or 3 i really think that would be a bad idea because i hate six sams and with more than one rota, that deck will get stronger than it alredy is Greg147 (talk • contribs) 02:59, June 30, 2014 (UTC)

Avarice will not come down, Pot of Dichotomy is a fair replacement for it. Sonic, while OP, is limited to blackwings and doesn't make them an unstoppable game-breaker. Strike fighter still has its old effect in the TCG until it is reprinted with the new one. when that happens there is no doubt it will come down, but til then its still the most broken OTK maker of all time. The Hands aren't all that bad. Beelze is nowhere near banworthy, flashback a few years and yes it would be, but so many staples get rid of it effortlessly. Fiendish chain, ARK, Castel (when it gets here), Breakthrough skill, D. Prison, etc. so many ways to kill it, it goes to shwo that "Can't die by card effect" isn't that great of an effect anymoreDreadKaiser (talk • contribs) 04:21, June 30, 2014 (UTC)

Beelze is fine, indestructible effects aren't what they used to be and there are lots of ways to easily play around him nowadays, notably 101, D-Prison, Compulsory, and Fiendish Chain/Breakthrough Skill (then something that destroys). Exciton is powerful, but you have to be losing to use it, which makes it more of a tide-turner than a win-moar card, since you can't use it while you're winning. I agree completely with Rulers, Soul Charge, Hootcake, Grand Mole, Faith, and Monk. Avarice is too good to come back, it rewards you for mindlessly over-extending monsters because after they die, you can just play Avarice, put em all back, get a pot of greed, and do it all over again. Not to mention Dichotomy is a fair version of it. Black Sonic is too situational, it's not going to be pulled off very often and Blackwings in general aren't good. The Hands are balanced and can stay at 3, they have to be destroyed and can only summon themselves from the deck. DSF can come back when we get the errata, Tenki to 2, I'm a bit on the fence about it, I think it'd be better to leave it at 3 while you hit something out of Bujins themselves, and Fire Fists are fine where they're at. Formula can come down to 2 only if you ban Hyper Librarian first. Getting +3's by summoning multiples in the same turn (via machine duplication on tuningware while T.G. Hyper is up) is too strong. Machine Duplication might also prevent Trooper from going to 3, but with Kuribandit now largely outclassing Trooper, I won't be too bad with it. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 13:32, July 1, 2014 (UTC)

CONFIRMED TCG LIST

Forbidden:

  • No changes

Limited:

Semi-Limited:

No longer Limited:

--Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 17:36, July 3, 2014 (UTC)

Wasn't expecting Goyo (I've mentioned that it might not be that bad up above in the comments <Yang-Zing gonna be interesting>) or Formula. I question Formula, but the rest doesn't seem that bad. Surprised Soul Charge missed the list, but the card also hasn't been the bane that everyone though it would be. --Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 17:41, July 3, 2014 (UTC)
Wait... What ? What the hell is that banlist ? Almost nothing will change in meta with that list ! KiryuRPG (talk • contribs) 17:39, July 3, 2014 (UTC)
That's Konami's TCG list for 3 months. So yeah, nothing will change. But the September list will probably change things up quite a bit. One thing the ROTA lowering does is kinda tell us that Stratos is probably never coming back, which I'm more than okay with. --Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 17:41, July 3, 2014 (UTC)
This is a quite old, but we might be able to apply some logic from them to this list.
Part 1
Part 2
Part 3
--Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 17:49, July 3, 2014 (UTC)

Absolutely half-assed list, but I can't say I'm surprised, this is the list right before worlds after all, and I can't say I expected it to be very long. The only thing I completely disagree with is Goyo, and I'm a bit on the fence about Formula. The rest is ok, I guess... Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 20:27, July 3, 2014 (UTC)

Well, Goyo is certainly... interesting... Mirror Force and DPrison to 3 I like; Formula, RoTA, and MoFaith to 2 I REALLY like; Geargiagear to 1 I also REALLY like... but Goyo to 1...

All in all, it looks like Synchro decks are receiving a significant boost. TheOtherWhiteNerd2 (talk • contribs) 22:41, July 3, 2014 (UTC)

Many people think that Goyo to one is just to promote Legendary Collection 5, but LC5 comes out in October, almost an entire month after this format list is over. --Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 01:28, July 4, 2014 (UTC)
Also, I'm willing to try Goyo. The decks that could make him just aren't around. While Yang-Zing look promising in the future, there's also Shaddolls and Tellaknights too. I think we should give Goyo a shot, he might not be that bad now. --Dark Ace SP (TalkPage) 01:30, July 4, 2014 (UTC)
Goyo is also a lot easier to play around now than it was before. With triple Mirror Force, triple Dimensional Prison, Warning, Black Horn, Moralltach, Sanctum, and tons of other removal cards, he might not be that big of a problem. It's at least worth a shot. Hastydemon2 (talk • contribs) 03:22, July 4, 2014 (UTC)
Eh, I can kinda understand that, a friend of mine said that it's basically just another giant beatstick like BLS in the current meta, and we all know how little BLS has done over the past few years. But still, it's better that we get more balanced synchro support than some poorly designed card like Goyo. Ninety-eight (talk • contribs) 11:11, July 4, 2014 (UTC)
Retrieved from "https://yugipedia.com/index.php?title=Forum:July_2014_Banlist_Predictions&oldid=2802714"