Talk:Negate Attack (manga)

This is the talk page for discussing the page, Negate Attack (manga).
This page is for discussing how to improve the page. For general discussion and comments, use the general discussion forum. To ask about rulings or how cards work, use the ruling queries forum. To get help with building a Deck, use the Deck help forum. Please sign and date your posts by typing four tildes (~~~~). Put new text under old text. Click here to start a new topic.	Please try to Be polite Assume good faith Be welcoming

Split

If the fact, that it uses a note, rather than already being split is what's making anyone uncertain about splitting the page, you can disregard that.

Viz switched back and forth between Spell and Trap:

• It was labelled a Trap, but called a Spell when used by the ventriloquist.
• For the rest of Duelist Kingdom, it was a Trap.
• Kaiba VS Duel Machine and R, it was a Spell.
• GX, it was back to being a Trap.

I knew it also changed type in the Japanese manga, but didn't feel like going through all appearances at the time I made that edit, so I just stuck in a vague note.

But it does seem to consistently be a Spell with the more poetic lore throughout the original and R. And a Trap with the OCG lore for everything since then. So I'm okay with the split. -- Deltaneos (talk) 13:48, January 10, 2016 (UTC)

I don't read the manga, so I and try and avoid making manga splits, instead just asking about them based on the content on the wiki.

I would like to point out one issue with the split though: this image indicates that it was a Spell Card with the OCG-like lore at some point in GX. While I think original/R poetic lore and GX-on OCG-like lore should be separate pages from each other, I don't know about the GX Spell Card; I think a change in card type (in the Japanese version) should be grounds for a split, and I think the old lore and new lore are different enough to split, so that would be 3 pages. Anyone have any thoughts on that issue? (Also, knowing which chapters in GX it was a Spell Card would be helpful.) --SnorlaxMonster 16:48, January 10, 2016 (UTC)

Actually, it was a Spell in GX until its last two uses in that manga (so chapters 51 and 63). So it was a Spell most of the time in GX as well. Cheesedude (talk • contribs) 21:49, January 10, 2016 (UTC)