Forum:What to put on? What to take off?

Okay, instead of he usual "What should go on the list", why not we discuss what should be taken OFF the list.

My thoughts:

---

Thousand-Eyes Restrict (Not that powerful, and no one would ever run two of the weakest monsters in the same Deck, not to mention it's easy to take out with 1f1 cards.)

Tsukuyomi (Have you noticed that Time Seal is banned? She's incredibly slow, and the effect is just a book of moon effect)

Magician of Faith (Who really cares? 1 Spell from the grave for one incredibly weak monster, not to mention that she'd be long gone before she could be re-used.)

Premature Burial (Ever heard of Call of the Haunted? It's easier to take out too, being an equip spell and having to pay 800 Life points to use...)

Spirit Reaper (Weakest. Card. Ever. Doesn't matter if it can't be destroyed by battle, it's still suicidal)

Burial From a Different Dimension (Yeah, cause this card makes OTKs and FTKs and is soooo broken /sarcasm)

Destiny Draw (We all know that it should be semi'd)

The Transmigration Prophecy (Yeah, cause this card is soooooooooooo broken. Isn't there a pot spell that's exactly like this? I don't see this card as potentially dangerous in anyway)

Wall of Revealing Light (Yeah, so I pay 3000 Life Points to stall for a turn, then you Mystical Space Typhoon it next turn. YIPPEE!)

Goblin Zombie (Not sure, not entirely broken, but does earch incredibly well)

Cyber Dragon (Ever heard of this card called The Tricky? )

Magical Stone Excavation (Yeah, since everyone would rather dump two cards to re-use a weak 1f1 Spell, instead of use Serial Spell or something. No one has used this in AGES!)

Royal Decree (Yeah, 'cause people run this in threes /sarcasm)

Skill Drain (See Royal Decree)

Ultimate Offering (Yeah, cause I'd so run this in threes and hope to get it as a dead draw)

---

Just my thoughts, I haven't decided where they might go yet. Post your thoughts, and if you need a link: http://www.yugioh-card.com/en/limited/

"Premature Burial" is Forbidden because it is abused for endless "Reborns" by "Brionac, Dragon of the Ice Barrier" and "Dewloren, Tiger King of the Ice Barrier". "Burial from a Different Dimension" spams "Plaguespreader Zombie", "Mezuki", and "Necro Gardna". DemonGodAsura (talk • contribs) 22:20, August 1, 2010 (UTC)

I use Instant Fusion to summon Thousand-Eyes Restrict, equip a monster then tribute it. You lose 1 monster (which gets sent to the grave, not destroyed), I gain a tribute monster. The Transmigration Prophecy is limited because it can bring itself back to the deck. Spirit Reaper and Wall of Revealing Light is there to prevent boring stall decks. --Hozu (talk • contribs) 14:01, August 2, 2010 (UTC)

Thousand-Eyes Restrict isn't a big problem, he's just a weaker Underground Arachnid who is easier to summon, and a built in Spellbinding Circle Effect. Not to mention that he acts Malefic, so he's better not to use unless he saves you. Wall of Revealing Light: pay 3000 Life Points and stall for a turn or two, then it's destroyed and you payed more than a third of your LP for nothing. If Spirit Reaper is limited, why not this guy? I see your point on Transmigration, though. Drew-Gi-Oh! (talk • contribs) 00:53, August 3, 2010 (UTC)

• @OP: You're a horrible player.

- Thousand-Eyes Restrict was originally banned because of the loop it had with Scapegoat, Metamorphosis and Tsukuyomi. While the loop isn't there anymore, Thousand-Eyes Restrict is still a very powerful Fusion monster. And BTB, low ATK means nothing.

- Tsukuyomi being unbanned is one of the only things I agree with. The format is too fast for it to really be able to abuse tons of cards, and it's definitely not ban-worthy anymore.

- Magician of Faith, on the other hand, would never be unbanned alongside Tsukuyomi. It has a very powerful effect that works in almost any deck by itself, let alone having recycling power.

- Brionac, Arms Hole and Dewloren will make sure that Premature Burial stays banned.

- Spirit Reaper was originally limited, similar to Marshmallon, because of it's immunity to destruction, but people disregard it's other ability - attacking directly with it = discard. It's a great effect, albeit, Reaper isn't used too much in the game anymore.

- If you don't know what you're talking about, don't talk about Burial, kthnx.

- Prophecy was used as tech a few formats back, but isn't so threatening anymore. It has nothing to do with it being able to send itself back.

- Goblin Zombie gives great search power to Zombies, but will likely stay on the list to keep nerfing them.

- Ever heard of the term "crap card"? a.k.a The Tricky. Cyber Dragon use was widespread a few formats ago, and even with it being semi'd, it's starting to be used again, although not to the same degree. Cyber Dragon is also a free summon with no cost.

- You clearly know nothing about the game. Magical Stone Excavation is used in numerous OTKs and FTKs. Get your facts straight.

- They clearly did at one point if it's been semi'd. -_-

- Skill Drain helps a lot of anti-meta decks out.

- Ultimate Offering was used in OTKs.

All in all, you really don't know much about the game, and yet you run your mouth like you do. Fail.--YamiWheeler (talk • contribs) 01:08, August 3, 2010 (UTC)

Why are you insulting me? I'm leaving my opinion, as I have the right to do, and you do too. I do indeed know quite a bit about the game, not about the rulings and releases, but I do know the strengths and weaknesses of certain cards. Albeit, I didn't think there would be a loop with Premature Burial (I thought it's rulings were like Call of the Haunted, where if it's removed from the field, the monster SS'd is sent back tot he grave.) What OTKs were Magical Stone Excavation used in? Ultmate Offering is, of course, involved in OTKs (I use one OTK myself), but only one would ever be needed, because of it's continuous effect. --Drew-Gi-Oh! (talk • contribs) 03:24, August 3, 2010 (UTC)

I believe he was typing to you in that tone of voice (LOL) because the comments you left beside the cards made it seem as though you knew what you were talking about, although they were clearly ignorant remarks(no offense intended). If you would have posted things like "I dunno why these cards are banned" instead of this instance: "Thousand Eyes Restrict doesn't deserve to be on the banlist because people run one for one destruction cards" then you might have appeared to not sound n00bi$h. Goblinpunch787

• I'm insulting you partly because of this. ^ And also because, while you have an opinion and are "entitled" to it, it's a terrible opinion based on very little knowledge and I'm just as entitled to tear it down. You don't know as much about the game as you think you do. For example, the reasons why The Tricky and Serial Spell are horrible cards, or the reason why cards like Magician of Faith and Spirit Reaper are good. Also, Premature Burial's loop isn't ruling-related - it's written in the text of the card. If you just did a bit more research, you'd see that Magical Stone Excavation is used in OTKs and FTKs like Magical Explosion FTK (the reason why it was hit to begin with), Exodia, Empty Jar, etc. Many lesser OTKs also use Magical Stone Excavation on a regular basis. And obviously, having 3 copies of Ultimate Offering in the deck would raise the consistency of a deck that OTK'd using it, even if you ignore the fact that running 1 means your OTK is incredibly easy to stop. Normally, I stay away from ignorant threads (like lololgreatshogunshienshouldbebanned!), but this one was just filled with so much ignorance that I couldn't not say something.--YamiWheeler (talk • contribs) 11:19, August 3, 2010 (UTC)