Forum:Magician's Right / Left Hand rulings

Hello, I have questions regarding Magician's Right Hand and Magician's Left Hand, more precisely when used with Performapal Sky Magician. I have Sky magician face-up on my field, as well as Left Hand face-up; I also have Right Hand (the one that negates spells) in my hand. It's my opponent's turn and they activate a spell card called X, their 1st spell card that turn. QUESTION 1: If i do nothing to respond to X and it resolves properly, my opponent then activates (not as part of a chain) a 2nd spell, Y. If i activate Sky magician's effect, bounce my Left Hand and activate Right Hand, can Right hand negate Y, the 2nd spell of that turn (but the first spell that was used AFTER Right Hand became active)?

Question 2: For this case, i control sky magician and have only Right Hand face-up on the field. My opponent activates their 1st spell that turn, Spell X, and Right Hand negates it. Now, if they activate a 2nd spell (Y) and i decide to bounce Right Hand and activate it again as part of a chain (Chain link 1: Y is activate; Chain link 2: Sky magician's bounce + reactivation of Right Hand is activated), could i negate the 2nd spell Y as well (since it's the first one activated AFTER Right Hand's second activation)?

Thank you for your time, good luck. Imadmagician (talk • contribs) 12:35, November 24, 2017 (UTC)

For Question 1: X would be the spell negated. For Question 2: Y would be negated if you use/chain Sky Magician after X's negation is resolved.BlazeWu (talk • contribs) 20:51, November 24, 2017 (UTC)

To Blazewu: I need a small clarification about answer 1 please: the 1st spell X had already resolved properly because there was no "Right Hand" on the field. The thing is, AFTER X had resolved properly, I proceed to activate "Right Hand" from my hand. Let's put it a simpler way: It's my turn, I have three set spell / trap cards, any face-up continuous spell card (let's say for instance Supply Squad), & also Magician's Right Hand in my own hand. My opponent activates for instance Mystical Space Typhoon during my turn to target a set card of mine, and i let it resolve, destroying that set card. After that, they activate another quick-play, let's say Twin Twisters, to destroy my two remaining set cards. Suppose I activate Sky Magician's effect to bounce Supply Squad (or whatever continuous spell i have) and replace it with Right Hand as chain link 2 to Twin Twisters' chain link 1: would twin twisters, the 2nd spell my opponent used that turn - BUT, the first they used while Right Hand was on the field - be negated? Thanks, and sorry for the fumble. Imadmagician (talk • contribs) 12:27, November 25, 2017 (UTC)