Difference between revisions of "Card Rulings:Question"
(remove unsourced OCG rulings; the current database page does not list them) |
|||
| (16 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | {{Rulings | + | {{Navigation}} |
| − | |name | + | |
| − | | | + | ==TCG Rulings== |
| + | ===Judge Program Forum Rulings=== | ||
| + | {{RulingFlagged |TCGJudgeProgram = | ||
| + | * In place of declaring a FULL card name, a precise description of a card's stats, appearance, and/or effects, is considered acceptable so long as both players are in clear agreement over which card is being described. | ||
| + | ** Saying "Dekoichi" instead of "[[Dekoichi the Battlechanted Locomotive]]" is acceptable as long as there isn't another card with the name "Dekoichi". | ||
| + | ** In the case of a card like "[[Luster Dragon]]", since the [[Card Errata:Luster Dragon 2|original printing]] of "[[Luster Dragon 2|Luster Dragon #2]]" did not have the #2 by its card name, you should ask the player for additional information. If they say "The Level 6 one" is then enough information provided so that both players know which card it is.<ref>[https://tcg.konami-europe.com/judgeforum/forum/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=180&sid=f3a7cd3f38ab3b050791574b6c98f7d1 Konami Judge Program Forum]: Question / Mind Crush / Prohibition / ETC. vs Card Names</ref> | ||
}} | }} | ||
| − | * Remember that you cannot shuffle your [[Graveyard]] or change the order of cards in your Graveyard at any time. | + | ==Previously Official Rulings== |
| + | {{Previously Official Rulings |UDE's Rulings = | ||
| + | * Remember that you cannot shuffle your [[Graveyard]] or change the order of cards in your Graveyard at any time. | ||
| − | * If a [[monster]] is named with "[[Question]]" that could not be [[Special Summon]]ed, "Question"’s [[effect]] disappears and the monster is neither Special Summoned nor removed from play. So the effect of "Question" disappears if the bottom monster is incorrectly named and is "[[Helpoemer]]", "[[Dark Ruler Ha Des]]", etc. | + | * If a [[monster]] is named with "[[Question]]" that could not be [[Special Summon]]ed, "Question"’s [[effect]] disappears and the monster is neither Special Summoned nor removed from play. So the effect of "Question" disappears if the bottom monster is incorrectly named and is "[[Helpoemer]]", "[[Dark Ruler Ha Des]]", etc. |
* If you would Special Summon "[[Tyrant Dragon]]" from the Graveyard using "Question", you must [[Tribute]] 1 [[Dragon]] and if you cannot you cannot Special Summon "Tyrant Dragon" and the effect of "Question" disappears. | * If you would Special Summon "[[Tyrant Dragon]]" from the Graveyard using "Question", you must [[Tribute]] 1 [[Dragon]] and if you cannot you cannot Special Summon "Tyrant Dragon" and the effect of "Question" disappears. | ||
| − | ==Mentions in Other Rulings== | + | ====Mentions in Other Rulings==== |
| − | * [ | + | * '''[[Card Rulings:Necrovalley|Necrovalley]]''': "[[Necrovalley]]" negates any effect that targets a card or cards in the Graveyard. So "[[Necrovalley]]" WILL negate the effect of: ..."[[Question]]"...<ref group=Notes name="PSCT target">The latest print of "Necrovalley" has [[Problem-Solving Card Text]] which states that it negates the effects of cards that move cards in the Graveyard to other locations, regardless of whether or not they target. Despite this effect not targeting, this ruling is correct that it is negated by "Necrovalley".</ref> |
| + | }} | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Notes== | ||
| + | <references group=Notes/> | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==References== | ||
| + | <references/> | ||
Latest revision as of 09:47, 5 October 2023
Contents
TCG Rulings
Judge Program Forum Rulings
 | These Ruling(s) have not been confirmed as applicable to the TCG.[Notes 1] |
- In place of declaring a FULL card name, a precise description of a card's stats, appearance, and/or effects, is considered acceptable so long as both players are in clear agreement over which card is being described.
- Saying "Dekoichi" instead of "Dekoichi the Battlechanted Locomotive" is acceptable as long as there isn't another card with the name "Dekoichi".
- In the case of a card like "Luster Dragon", since the original printing of "Luster Dragon #2" did not have the #2 by its card name, you should ask the player for additional information. If they say "The Level 6 one" is then enough information provided so that both players know which card it is.[1]
Previously Official Rulings
| These TCG rulings were issued by Upper Deck Entertainment and have since been declared unofficial by Konami.[2] They were previously considered official and can still be correct, as long as they follow the official gameplay rules, or unless Konami has issued a ruling that says otherwise. References: [3][4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11] |
- Remember that you cannot shuffle your Graveyard or change the order of cards in your Graveyard at any time.
- If a monster is named with "Question" that could not be Special Summoned, "Question"’s effect disappears and the monster is neither Special Summoned nor removed from play. So the effect of "Question" disappears if the bottom monster is incorrectly named and is "Helpoemer", "Dark Ruler Ha Des", etc.
- If you would Special Summon "Tyrant Dragon" from the Graveyard using "Question", you must Tribute 1 Dragon and if you cannot you cannot Special Summon "Tyrant Dragon" and the effect of "Question" disappears.
Mentions in Other Rulings
- Necrovalley: "Necrovalley" negates any effect that targets a card or cards in the Graveyard. So "Necrovalley" WILL negate the effect of: ..."Question"...[Notes 2]
Notes
- ↑ Konami Judge Program Rulings are considered unverified, as their source(s) are not publicly viewable. They are not confirmed as applicable to the TCG until they have been officially published by Konami.
- ↑ The latest print of "Necrovalley" has Problem-Solving Card Text which states that it negates the effects of cards that move cards in the Graveyard to other locations, regardless of whether or not they target. Despite this effect not targeting, this ruling is correct that it is negated by "Necrovalley".
References
- ↑ Konami Judge Program Forum: Question / Mind Crush / Prohibition / ETC. vs Card Names
- ↑ Konami Judge Program Forum: Individual Email Rulings VS Individual Card Rulings
- ↑ UDE FAQ: Individual Card Rulings [A-C]
- ↑ UDE FAQ: Individual Card Rulings [D-E]
- ↑ UDE FAQ: Individual Card Rulings [F-H]
- ↑ UDE FAQ: Individual Card Rulings [I-K]
- ↑ UDE FAQ: Individual Card Rulings [L-O]
- ↑ UDE FAQ: Individual Card Rulings [P-R]
- ↑ UDE FAQ: Individual Card Rulings [S-T]
- ↑ UDE FAQ: Individual Card Rulings [U-Z]
- ↑ UDE FAQ: SPECIFIC CARDS RULINGS
