Forum:Black Rose Deck (My Plant Deck)

Here is My "Back Garden" Deck, yeah i screwed up the Title! lol What do you guys think? Any constructive criticism?

• OK so I've worked on my deck and it has been very much updated please let me kn0w what you guys think!

--Harpie King 13:57 April 1, 2010 (OST)

60-card deck limit!

Have you read the most recent rules? You Can Not have more then 60 cards in your deck. You don't even have Black Garden in your deck, why do you name it such?

Not to mention most players don't want much more then 45 cards in their deck because it Severely cuts your odds of getting the right cards you need at the right time if you have a Massive deck size.

This deck looks like nothing more then your complete collection of plant related cards.. That's a very poor deck strategy.

Thin it down to 50 cards MAX, and Then we can start talking tips and advice and constructive critisism. Thorn of RosenYubel 00:35, March 28, 2010 (UTC)

... 29 monsters + 29 spells + 13 traps = 71 cards. 71 > 60 You can ONLY have 60 cards in your deck MAX.

There's so many useless cards in your deck I'm not even going to bother helping you until you put some serious thought into thinning it down to 50 cards and developing a central strategy.

I can assure you a central strategy and a small deck will ALWAYS do better then a huge assortment of cards that are "sorta related, they're all plant-type anyway." Yes, it will do better EVEN if you choose not to follow any of the restrictions. Thorn of RosenYubel 21:49, April 4, 2010 (UTC)

OK, what cards should go?

Ok so what cards do you suggest to get rid of?

• i really want this o be a good deck, please help!

Author 12:32, April 6, 2010 (UTC)

That entirely depends on what strategy you want your deck to use, be that beatdown, burn, token summoning, OTK, synchro, etc.

I'm surprized you can't figure out what cards are useless on your own..

But for starters: Griggle, Homunculus the Alchemic Being, Jerry Beans Man, Des Dendle, Rainbow Flower, Woodland Sprite,Cursed Fig, and All your E-Hero related cards.

Those cards do nothing to further your strategy, and are Not useful for utility.

I'll let you figure out the rest, since it will help you learn deckbuilding, and the spells and traps need to be tuned for your strategy, which is currently unknown atm. Come back with a 40-45 Max card deck (since I already cut out almost 10 cards for you) and I'll help you fine tune your strategy and give you tips and card suggestions. If you have any questions about why exactly I dropped a card, feel free to ask.Thorn of RosenYubel 12:13, April 6, 2010 (UTC)

UPDATES

1. 1. Des Dendle & Griggle have been removed as they are pretty much useless in my deck, instead they have been replaced with 2x Botanical Girl as this could help me place as many plants on the field as possible.

• Also I've removed Ancient Leaf as lets face it, who ever has 9000 life points at any point in an official tournament? And one Ivy shackles has been completely removed as i dont see it helping me in any way while its in my deck.
• Now where to go next?
• Also removed all Copy Plants as they are no use to me whatsoever

What's next? Drop the Man Eater and Mushroom Man (both low level, poor atk/def, and no effect), and then drop the entire deck down to 45 cards max, do not add anything until you get below 45 cards, and take out anything that does not help further your central strategy. I'm not helping you again until I see a new deck list with 45 cards Max in it. Thorn of RosenYubel 20:14, April 6, 2010 (UTC)