Forum:Honest Vs Honest
| Forums: | Index → Help desk → Honest Vs Honest Please sign your comments with ~~~~. See Help:Signatures and Help:Talk pages for further information. |
 | This forum thread has been unedited for 5342 days and is considered archived. Please don't add to the discussion, unless absolutely necessary. |
Both player have Blue-Eyes White Dragon on the field and Honest in their hand. Player A's Blue-Eyes White Dragon attack player B's. Player A, as the turn player has the Priority to activate honest effect first (correct me if I am wrong) and use it as Chain link 1. Player B then chain it with his honest and become chain link 2. If these are right, player B's Blue-Eyes White Dragon ATK will become
6000 and Player A's will become 9000, right?
Question 1
So, no matter how many honest chained, in the event of Honest vs Honest effect, is the player who activate honest first (the turn player) will win the battle?
Question 2
Can the attacked player (non-turn player) activate honest first without the turn player passed his priority?
Question 3
Can 2 honest activate at a SEGOC?
Sumabek 13:23, September 9, 2009 (UTC)
- "Honest" is a really complicated card, so I suggest that you look at Breakdown of the Battle Phase. For this, we will use the TCG Damage Step.
- Yes, that example is correct, assuming that the Turn Player activated his "Honest" during Damage Calculation (Sub-Step 4). This is because there can only be one Chain during Damage Calculation.
- 1) The last "Honest" to resolve will win. If all "Honest"s are activated in one Chain, then the first one to activate will be the last one to resolve, so it will win.
- If the Turn Player isn't smart, he may activate "Honest" before Damage Calculation (Sub-Step 3, or possibly earlier). Then, the non-Turn Player may activate his "Honest" during Damage Calculation. The non-Turn Player's copy is the last one to resolve, so it will win.
- 2) He cannot.
- Note that you don't proceed to the next Sub-Step until both players agree. So if the Turn Player wants to move from "before Damage Calculation" (Sub-Step 3) to Damage Calculation (Sub-Step 4), then the non-Turn Player may disagree and activate his copy of "Honest".
- 3) It's not a SEGOC, since the effect isn't a Trigger Effect. But, multiple copies can be activated in the same Chain. It would be the same as both players trying to activate "Torrential Tribute" in response to a Summon.
- --Deus Ex Machina (Talk) 19:00, September 9, 2009 (UTC)
